Critics Consensus

The Gentlemen is Vintage Guy Ritchie

Plus, The Turning spins a twisty but unsatisfying tale, and Color out of Space and Zombi Child are Certified Fresh.

by | January 23, 2020 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a retiring kingpin (The Gentlemen, starring Matthew McConaughey and Hugh Grant) and a bedeviled babysitter (The Turning, starring Mackenzie Davis and Finn Wolfhard). What are the critics saying?


The Gentlemen (2020) 73%

Director Guy Ritchie has spent the past several years helming big-budget Hollywood projects like the Sherlock Holmes movies, The Man from U.N.C.L.E., 2017’s King Arthur: Legend of the Sword, and last year’s live-action remake of Disney’s Aladdin. But it’s worth remembering that he initially made a name for himself with sprawling crime capers led by ensemble casts, like Lock, Stock and Two Smoking Barrels and Snatch. Much like Rian Johnson did recently with Knives Out, Ritchie returns to his roots this week with The Gentlemen, hoping to recapture the same magic that made him a studio darling. Matthew McConaughey leads the way as Michael “Mickey” Pearson, an American ex-pat in London who rules over a vast marijuana empire. When Mickey decides he wants to sell off his business and retire, a number of interested parties emerge, setting off a war of double-crosses as everyone struggles to get the upper hand. In other words, this is classic Guy Ritchie territory, and most critics say it’s a witty, entertaining, fast-paced comedy that benefits from some top-notch talent, particularly Hugh Grant and Colin Farrell at their scenery-chewing best. That said, Ritchie’s penchant for colorful language and tendency to play sordid situations for laughs — bestiality, casual and frequent racism, and a rape figure into the narrative here — aren’t for everyone, so it’s likely to shock anyone only familiar with his more mainstream fare.


The Turning (2020) 12%

Henry James’ classic novella The Turn of the Screw is one of the most famous examples of open-ended gothic horror, and it’s been the subject of classroom debates ever since it was first published in 1898. So it’s fitting that it has seen numerous screen adaptations, many of which offer different interpretations of what exactly the story communicates. The latest is this week’s The Turning, brought to us courtesy of director Floria Sigismondi (The Runaways, Marvel’s DaredevilThe Handmaid’s Tale), who updates the story for a 1990s setting, and critics say it’s unnecessary and unnecessarily frustrating. Mackenzie Davis stars as Kate, the new nanny to orphaned high-society siblings Miles (Finn Wolfhard) and Flora Fairchild (Brooklynn Prince), who live on a large, spooky estate in Maine in the care of their maid. Kate quickly discovers that neither the children nor the house is quite normal, and when mysterious things begin to happen, she finds herself ill-equipped to make sense of any of it. Unfortunately, the critics largely also failed to make much sense of the film, which fails to generate much dread from its repeated images of creepy doll faces and ghostly specters in the distance en route to a baffling climax. James’ original story is clearly meant to inspire discussion, but The Turning isn’t likely to spark much other than bewilderment and maybe a little regret.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • I Wish I Knew (Hai shang chuan qi) (2020)Jia Zhangke’s documentary portrait of Shanghai and its remarkable history, is at 100%.
  • Color Out of Space (2020) , starring Nicolas Cage in an adaptation of the H.P. Lovecraft short story of the same title, about the effects of a meteorite on a family living in rural Massachusetts, is Certified Fresh at 87%.
  • Zombi Child (2020) , following two parallel stories about a sugar plantation worker in 1962 Haiti and his granddaughter, who attends a boarding school in present-day France, is Certified Fresh at 87%.
  • The Last Full Measure (2020) , featuring a star-studded cast in a based-on-true-events drama about a Pentagon staffer’s investigation of a Medal of Honor request for a Vietnam War hero, is at 63%.
  • Quezon's Game (2020) , a drama about former Filipino President Manuel Quezon’s efforts to rescue Jews during the Holocaust, is at 29%.
  • John Henry (2020) , starring Terry Crews as a former gang member who turns to vigilante justice when he encounters two children on the run from the leader of the gang he left, is at 0%.

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

Fall TV Marvel Disney Channel video animated Discovery Channel First Reviews singing competition 2019 MSNBC Women's History Month Summer robots kids adventure halloween GLAAD Stephen King Ghostbusters Creative Arts Emmys Trailer Endgame jamie lee curtis cancelled TV shows psycho quibi LGBT YouTube Premium E! Disney streaming service YA justice league Cannes New York Comic Con Watching Series DC Universe NYCC TCA biography WGN Pixar Star Trek cinemax Mudbound cats Horror cops name the review PBS TV Land Lionsgate San Diego Comic-Con Comics on TV TCA 2017 Biopics composers Disney Sundance mockumentary Dark Horse Comics VH1 richard e. Grant golden globes ABC anthology Fantasy Pop Hallmark Christmas movies Spike Marvel Studios breaking bad Netflix Christmas movies DC Comics toy story Thanksgiving war TLC Valentine's Day ESPN Song of Ice and Fire History doctor who Fox News LGBTQ CBS All Access documentary Masterpiece Sci-Fi The CW comiccon Rocketman hist movie science fiction USA MCU Brie Larson Heroines screenings sequel Spring TV Rock Academy Awards Amazon Prime Video joker Turner 71st Emmy Awards TCM Set visit Quiz spider-man Musicals Apple TV+ technology Black Mirror crime thriller Baby Yoda rotten movies we love teaser Walt Disney Pictures Red Carpet romantic comedy Lucasfilm VICE blockbuster television BBC America werewolf Mary Poppins Returns Winter TV 45 facebook Country Year in Review crime First Look Election Syfy Turner Classic Movies blaxploitation canceled TV shows cancelled TV series game show nature CBS 20th Century Fox Freeform Arrowverse Sundance Now Shondaland Holidays Bravo thriller Apple children's TV Opinion Shudder hispanic natural history transformers award winner casting Super Bowl Netflix elevated horror Nat Geo Oscars The Walking Dead directors A24 TV Amazon Trophy Talk screen actors guild Best and Worst sitcom Marvel Television green book Hallmark what to watch Drama canceled versus political drama SXSW MTV Tarantino Comedy Extras Animation batman Rocky SDCC christmas movies Nickelodeon stand-up comedy space reboot IFC HBO Max docudrama Tumblr 2018 Vudu USA Network A&E game of thrones Nominations DirecTV HBO Interview Video Games Martial Arts Comic Book ghosts Elton John Toys DC streaming service CMT Teen south america vampires 007 Sneak Peek psychological thriller Star Wars Certified Fresh Paramount Network spanish language Britbox Film Columbia Pictures cars Logo Amazon Prime theme song Mindy Kaling President boxoffice Comedy Central series 2016 RT History DGA dramedy spinoff The Witch slashers sports medical drama Reality Competition Awards Awards Tour Winners ratings Grammys Holiday tv talk Adult Swim Lifetime Christmas movies cancelled television police drama comic Universal travel Western Epix dceu Peacock YouTube Red disaster Cosplay Ellie Kemper period drama Musical Reality AMC RT21 Calendar Warner Bros. adaptation Podcast harry potter X-Men National Geographic Tomatazos Marathons Anna Paquin cancelled historical drama Mary Tyler Moore dragons Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Tubi TCA Winter 2020 Film Festival Starz Pet Sematary cults APB independent Hulu Avengers YouTube dc CW Seed Infographic romance revenge Schedule miniseries festivals Chilling Adventures of Sabrina cooking serial killer El Rey Esquire Action FXX Rom-Com OWN Photos Box Office Christmas movies talk show Kids & Family foreign 2020 The Arrangement Writers Guild of America SundanceTV renewed TV shows Food Network comics Ovation Polls and Games politics See It Skip It Apple TV Plus OneApp Cartoon Network true crime GoT TruTV Family Emmys Binge Guide Sony Pictures zombies discovery GIFs free movies binge Sundance TV Disney Plus aliens social media finale indie NBC Trivia Acorn TV Showtime FOX 24 frames streaming Mary poppins Superheroes Mystery Captain marvel Lifetime CNN Pride Month TBS Chernobyl cartoon The Purge supernatural IFC Films latino diversity mutant WarnerMedia strong female leads Countdown Premiere Dates TNT anime crime drama ITV Paramount sag awards ABC Family FX Music spain PaleyFest zero dark thirty Emmy Nominations crossover witnail Superheroe TV renewals book based on movie unscripted zombie 21st Century Fox Classic Film American Society of Cinematographers Crunchyroll TIFF Disney+ Disney Plus 2015 Character Guide E3 2017 Crackle Television Academy BET spy thriller Spectrum Originals BBC Pirates