Critics Consensus

The Happytime Murders Won't Leave You in Stitches

Plus, Support the Girls is Certified Fresh, and guess A.X.L.'s Tomatometer.

by | August 23, 2018 | Comments

This weekend at the movies, we’ve got  Melissa McCarthy sharing the screen with some very profane puppets (The Happytime Murders, co-starring Elizabeth Banks and Maya Rudolph) and a boy and his robot dog (A.X.L., starring Alex Neustaedter and Becky G). What are the critics saying?


The Happytime Murders (2018) 24%

Jim Henson made tons of timeless family-friendly fare with his Muppets, but — as evidenced by film projects like The Dark Crystal and Labyrinth — he never saw puppetry strictly as kids’ stuff. It’s fitting, then, that his son Brian has taken that experimental spirit and injected it into The Happytime Murders, an R-rated black comedy following a murder mystery that takes place in a world populated by humans and puppets. A blend of ostensibly cuddly characters and enthusiastically adult humor, this is the kind of movie that sounds too gonzo to be real — and it almost wasn’t, enduring a decade in development before facing a lawsuit from the studio behind Sesame Street. After all that, it saddens us to report that Happytime is getting murdered by critics; reviews describe a clumsy comedy that’s too busy being aggressively edgy to actually be funny, never mind put a fresh spin on a story whose rough outline should be familiar to anyone who’s seen Who Framed Roger Rabbit. Despite that Henson pedigree and a terrific human cast that includes Melissa McCarthy, Maya Rudolph, Elizabeth Banks, and Joel McHale, this looks like one to stream — if you see it at all.


A.X.L. (2018) 27%

Hollywood is definitely taking that whole “dog days of summer” thing seriously this year. Last week, audiences went back in time to imagine the first boy-and-his-dog friendship in Alpha; this week, we’re taking a peek into the future with A.X.L., in which a teenage boy (Alex Neustaedter) happens upon a canine-shaped cutting-edge military robot. Naturally, the contraption’s bureaucratic minders are eager to get their creation back on its leash, so to speak — a quest complicated by the fact that our young hero has already bonded with his new four-legged pal. So it’s Benji plus Short Circuit, but does it add up to a winner with the critics? Unfortunately, we don’t know yet, because A.X.L. doesn’t have any reviews yet. That’s rarely a positive sign this late in the week, but while we wait to see for sure how things shake out, how about a round of Guess the Tomatometer?


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

Tag Cloud

Binge Guide streaming jamie lee curtis Mary poppins strong female leads Apple TV Plus foreign Superheroe cancelled television Discovery Channel Netflix Christmas movies Reality Competition Pirates Song of Ice and Fire Cosplay christmas movies disaster HBO Max Quiz Columbia Pictures USA scary movies green book aliens Creative Arts Emmys crime thriller Television Academy LGBTQ Turner Classic Movies Freeform Lifetime Funimation MTV Comics on TV BBC 007 LGBT Ellie Kemper Crackle DGA television south america American Society of Cinematographers Film Festival cancelled TV shows golden globes OneApp Watching Series quibi canceled NBC franchise Nickelodeon FX on Hulu Walt Disney Pictures SundanceTV The Arrangement Best and Worst cats TCA 2017 TCA Winter 2020 Dark Horse Comics Animation Endgame zombies Universal reviews Interview Grammys Marvel Television screenings Spike zero dark thirty Star Wars sports romance doctor who Country Adult Swim Extras Shondaland werewolf Captain marvel singing competition Cannes discovery ratings FX CW Seed Fall TV Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Superheroes halloween Pride Month A&E comics Set visit OWN spider-man SDCC harry potter TLC Esquire Awards Tour Paramount Network Election zombie Ovation Western indie slashers teaser witnail adventure transformers Disney Plus VH1 politics Apple TV+ toy story Fantasy Masterpiece cooking political drama Sony Pictures Britbox binge comic Chernobyl Sundance Anna Paquin El Rey ghosts Mystery Acorn TV book supernatural MSNBC Tomatazos Black History Month reboot Sci-Fi Rocky dragons 2019 Brie Larson blaxploitation Countdown versus E! spain war Polls and Games Syfy Mindy Kaling Red Carpet The CW Rock FOX VICE festivals Fox News romantic comedy universal monsters 2018 WarnerMedia talk show TBS Holidays thriller E3 Winter TV MCU Musical Disney hist Martial Arts richard e. Grant canceled TV shows what to watch AMC Stephen King batman science fiction Hulu justice league Starz psycho Heroines Oscars President name the review Spring TV Logo based on movie Ghostbusters dceu 2015 Sneak Peek Spectrum Originals mockumentary BBC America Action TNT stand-up comedy Awards Turner Comic Book police drama Sundance Now Pixar Paramount free movies Nominations Certified Fresh ABC Family Tumblr kids 2017 Lifetime Christmas movies Star Trek cancelled TV series Lionsgate YouTube Red Summer Trivia TCA spinoff technology mutant ITV Lucasfilm sequel Emmys Comedy First Reviews social media psychological thriller cancelled composers nature X-Men Hallmark vampires A24 Rocketman Opinion TCM animated Cartoon Network Holiday Kids & Family historical drama Emmy Nominations Warner Bros. Netflix Amazon Prime Video blockbuster IFC Films anthology TV natural history game show Rom-Com IFC anime crossover Travel Channel documentary DC Comics Video Games Disney Channel independent New York Comic Con screen actors guild DirecTV Christmas Mary Poppins Returns CBS All Access San Diego Comic-Con series latino Pet Sematary elevated horror crime Peacock comiccon movie directors Year in Review Apple Mary Tyler Moore Film hispanic PBS Toys Super Bowl WGN Disney streaming service The Purge Showtime Classic Film Marvel Studios Premiere Dates cinemax spy thriller finale YA Shudder Sundance TV adaptation Music GLAAD YouTube Premium Trailer Vudu Baby Yoda GoT dogs YouTube TruTV boxoffice Food Network sag awards Schedule Disney+ Disney Plus Thanksgiving Teen 24 frames Photos CMT NYCC USA Network Amazon Horror TIFF Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt HBO FXX Musicals docudrama Amazon Prime crime drama Podcast Women's History Month travel RT21 Amazon Studios space Academy Awards Avengers rotten movies we love sitcom First Look cops Hallmark Christmas movies serial killer 2016 breaking bad Calendar RT History Mudbound Infographic Writers Guild of America History facebook tv talk Tarantino renewed TV shows diversity game of thrones Tubi Biopics Arrowverse robots dc revenge Family National Geographic cartoon 45 Nat Geo Pop TV Crunchyroll SXSW Marathons ABC Reality Elton John Winners video dramedy DC streaming service miniseries ESPN Character Guide Epix period drama TV Land cults award winner PaleyFest The Witch Valentine's Day medical drama children's TV The Walking Dead spanish language biography Black Mirror APB casting TV renewals true crime unscripted joker DC Universe cars 20th Century Fox GIFs BET CBS movies Marvel 21st Century Fox 71st Emmy Awards Drama Bravo 2020 Trophy Talk Pop Comedy Central Box Office theme song See It Skip It CNN