Critics Consensus

The Lion King Is a Visual Feast, but Offers Nothing New

Critics say Disney's latest remake is a technical achievement, but it's essentially a rehash of the 1994 animated classic.

by | July 18, 2019 | Comments

This weekend at the movies, we’ve got a royal cub (The Lion King, featuring the voices of Donald Glover and Beyoncé Knowles-Carter). What are the critics saying?

The Lion King (2019) 52%

We’ve already gotten two of Disney’s live-action remakes of animated films from their canon — namely Dumbo back in March and Aladdin in May — but this week’s The Lion King was always the most anticipated of the bunch. Director Jon Favreau took on similar material when he helmed 2016’s The Jungle Book, which was both a critical and commercial success, so it made sense to tap him for another talking-animal movie with one less human in it. Multi-hyphenate talent Donald Glover takes on the role of adult Simba, while Beyoncé plays Nala, with Chiwetel Ejiofor as Scar, Billy Eichner as Timon, Seth Rogen as Pumbaa, and returning as the voice of Mufasa, James Earl Jones. Unfortunately, the critics haven’t all been on board for this return trip to the African wilderness. While most are quick to praise the technical craft that has gone into bringing the characters to life, many feel that it’s a double-edged sword, since the photorealistic nature of the animals necessarily limits their expressiveness. In addition, this new version of the story is essentially a shot-for-shot remake of the original that offers precious few new elements, which several critics found disappointing. With all of that in mind, overall reception to the film will largely hinge on whether audiences were hoping to see a new interpretation of the classic story or content to see the same tale retold, but with admittedly mind-blowing visuals. Either way, The Lion King is all but guaranteed to rule the box office this weekend, so Hakuna Matata to that.

Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

cooking Photos CBS Showtime finale Podcast Bravo Comic Book IFC Films Drama CMT Spike diversity ESPN animated HBO Max psychological thriller MTV Fall TV anime disaster TruTV ITV YouTube Red Music Pirates Universal zero dark thirty Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Logo ratings Opinion sports Election supernatural political drama Lucasfilm Emmy Nominations Shondaland Tumblr Nickelodeon elevated horror police drama revenge The Witch Amazon Prime Epix Elton John Thanksgiving Disney Kids & Family discovery sitcom sequel Walt Disney Pictures science fiction Brie Larson Certified Fresh comic Musicals 24 frames ABC YA APB strong female leads Trailer biography TBS Star Trek crime thriller Animation Comics on TV Comedy Central Nat Geo kids TCA Christmas Ellie Kemper 2018 Awards Tour Interview Set visit dramedy what to watch Extras blaxploitation SDCC Warner Bros. CBS All Access Musical Cartoon Network zombies justice league Infographic streaming Comedy Best and Worst HBO Emmys DC Universe MSNBC Watching Series Vudu binge El Rey Superheroe Black Mirror Britbox Family psycho Acorn TV Writers Guild of America cults Lionsgate golden globes Amazon Prime Video travel technology jamie lee curtis cops TV Western space VH1 WarnerMedia romance robots Rocketman Esquire Quiz E3 San Diego Comic-Con DGA mutant Video Games Mary poppins Adult Swim Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Film Festival Reality Competition GLAAD OWN TLC ABC Family green book AMC Rock casting Netflix Pride Month dc TCM crime drama spider-man NBC 2016 singing competition The Arrangement USA Network television Freeform Film zombie Stephen King Masterpiece LGBTQ Summer Captain marvel Marvel Character Guide war Mindy Kaling vampires MCU Heroines American Society of Cinematographers FX President The CW History hist Toys adventure talk show NYCC social media Countdown 2017 Lifetime natural history Trophy Talk facebook VICE SundanceTV miniseries DC streaming service 45 BBC America YouTube Premium nature Ovation Rocky teaser Superheroes cinemax Disney streaming service dragons Biopics DirecTV A&E spinoff witnail Super Bowl RT21 book spy thriller toy story dceu Columbia Pictures Polls and Games Fantasy Apple Mudbound New York Comic Con harry potter Mary Tyler Moore IFC Valentine's Day 21st Century Fox TV Land Disney Channel GoT Anna Paquin LGBT USA Pixar Binge Guide CW Seed Syfy Sundance Now politics Premiere Dates Red Carpet theme song Hulu GIFs game show award winner Spring TV DC Comics Amazon Nominations Star Wars Year in Review 20th Century Fox ghosts aliens First Look Dark Horse Comics Schedule Winners Tomatazos Food Network 007 TNT Shudder cats Trivia Spectrum Originals CNN BBC See It Skip It X-Men Country Starz Pet Sematary Women's History Month Ghostbusters serial killer comiccon true crime Rom-Com based on movie SXSW medical drama PBS Teen docudrama festivals crossover Awards anthology 2019 National Geographic unscripted tv talk children's TV Grammys cars Marathons historical drama Tarantino richard e. Grant Horror Winter TV period drama Cannes TIFF series mockumentary Chernobyl Oscars Sneak Peek E! Sundance Action Creative Arts Emmys Mystery RT History BET Reality adaptation FOX Pop transformers Holidays FXX quibi WGN crime Cosplay 2015 Paramount Network Martial Arts movies Mary Poppins Returns Calendar thriller boxoffice Song of Ice and Fire TCA 2017 doctor who composers Fox News Sony Pictures Paramount PaleyFest Box Office Crackle Sci-Fi