This Is Us Fans Tell Kate Not To Blame Herself for Jack's Death, But Should She?

Do you suspect Jack died a different way? Take our poll.

by | March 8, 2017 | Comments

Even by This Is Us standards, which is a three hankie minimum every week, “What Now?” was an emotional episode. Everyone knew William (Ron Cephas Jones)’s memorial would be powerful, but probably didn’t expect all the extra baggage it unleashed.


The service brought back Kate (Chrissy Metz)’s painful memories of Jack (Milo Ventimiglia)’s death, for one. The bride-to-be finally told her fiancé, Toby (Chris Sullivan), the heartbreaking reason she avoids talking about her father’s passing: She feels it’s her fault.

Earlier in the episode, young Kate (Mackenzie Hancsicsak) sensed the turmoil in Jack and Rebecca (Mandy Moore)’s marriage. In the car, she told Jack to try to work it out. But in the final scene of the episode, it appears Jack’s decision to fight for his marriage came at a bad time. He looks visibly drunk as he gets into his car, and the promo for the season finale hints at an automobile accident.

Immediately, Team Kate on Twitter jumped to her defense:

Perhaps more importantly, Jack of all people certainly wouldn’t want Kate feeling this way:

Some fans noticed the foreshadowing earlier in the episode:

Others are awaiting confirmation about what actually happened in the season finale next week. This Is Us confirmed five episodes in that Jack was not alive in 2016 (and hinted at his fate in the series premiere). We’ve seen glimpses of his funeral, but the show still hasn’t confirmed when it happened. Each week has contained a pretty major twist reveal, but maybe the biggest twist of all would be if the show kept fans in the dark about his fate until next season.

Then again, fans of This Is Us know there could always be another twist. Scarlett Splane, below, even noticed some behind-the-scenes photos of Jack meeting Rebecca again.

One thing is for sure, Kate and Jack’s relationship seems pretty universal:

And it wouldn’t be This Is Us without plenty of tears:

The season finale of This Is Us airs Tuesday, March 14 at 9/8C on NBC

Tag Cloud

dramedy Black Mirror cancelled TV series blockbuster jamie lee curtis OneApp Stephen King breaking bad supernatural golden globes LGBTQ San Diego Comic-Con medical drama Binge Guide The Walking Dead cooking SDCC DC Comics Anna Paquin game show Holidays cops halloween Holiday Comedy technology latino MTV Election Emmys name the review Mary poppins reboot The Purge Amazon Prime Video award winner Mudbound Western adaptation Watching Series Epix Musical hispanic joker comic Disney Channel natural history TV renewals NYCC Nominations FX Marathons Opinion what to watch rotten movies we love Sneak Peek singing competition batman Hallmark ratings Heroines finale Peacock Year in Review Marvel Studios A&E Mystery slashers TCA Winter 2020 RT History dceu X-Men Netflix Christmas movies police drama Calendar E! doctor who Sony Pictures First Reviews Chilling Adventures of Sabrina ABC Family book Set visit Martial Arts TLC comiccon TCA 2017 Country animated Spike E3 Rock facebook spy thriller canceled TCA Fantasy Bravo vampires social media Extras based on movie disaster Pet Sematary space Writers Guild of America Character Guide TBS strong female leads Interview DC Universe Logo Warner Bros. 2019 Marvel APB Summer Action witnail diversity DirecTV green book RT21 IFC Films transformers cancelled television LGBT First Look blaxploitation Television Academy Arrowverse cars NBC cancelled TV shows Trivia YA Film movie romance Tomatazos spider-man Tubi Masterpiece BET unscripted Dark Horse Comics 007 TV History Crunchyroll dragons christmas movies FOX sag awards Shudder Superheroes Kids & Family political drama SXSW directors Schedule Freeform Reality children's TV composers American Society of Cinematographers mutant Disney Apple documentary VICE crime toy story Star Trek Star Wars Cartoon Network 24 frames Fall TV Sundance TV free movies ABC Oscars 21st Century Fox streaming Discovery Channel Brie Larson Valentine's Day New York Comic Con science fiction Netflix Avengers 2017 Women's History Month revenge Shondaland ITV Showtime MCU Nat Geo sports Spring TV Disney streaming service kids USA ghosts TruTV Mary Poppins Returns Spectrum Originals Winners CBS Pop PaleyFest cults Nickelodeon Musicals screenings WGN binge Horror 2018 Video Games Comic Book YouTube Super Bowl crime drama HBO Max war spinoff richard e. Grant TNT Creative Arts Emmys Podcast Walt Disney Pictures cats Amazon 71st Emmy Awards DC streaming service Drama Trophy Talk Animation zero dark thirty renewed TV shows Captain marvel Quiz Sundance boxoffice Rocketman VH1 Comics on TV Infographic screen actors guild Crackle hist President Disney+ Disney Plus Sundance Now BBC Amazon Studios series sequel anthology discovery Polls and Games Pixar miniseries movies Lifetime Christmas movies GIFs Amazon Prime Apple TV+ true crime indie zombies teaser romantic comedy WarnerMedia National Geographic tv talk 2020 anime Disney Plus HBO Awards cancelled Superheroe Vudu Thanksgiving Premiere Dates TIFF Classic Film video Film Festival FXX The Witch Cannes Pirates Song of Ice and Fire werewolf Photos OWN Hallmark Christmas movies Best and Worst Starz GoT Marvel Television Esquire Mindy Kaling 45 Box Office Red Carpet Mary Tyler Moore Music Tumblr Sci-Fi Awards Tour PBS 2015 south america DGA dogs festivals serial killer Turner 20th Century Fox historical drama cinemax YouTube Red Rom-Com Paramount Network foreign SundanceTV harry potter Food Network A24 Grammys Adult Swim casting Lucasfilm versus ESPN mockumentary aliens 2016 El Rey Lionsgate Ellie Kemper biography Cosplay justice league Fox News docudrama Universal elevated horror Family Trailer nature independent psycho AMC Pride Month The Arrangement See It Skip It Emmy Nominations Columbia Pictures robots Certified Fresh Academy Awards TV Land psychological thriller BBC America travel YouTube Premium Winter TV USA Network CNN Hulu quibi The CW Baby Yoda thriller Reality Competition Biopics Elton John Teen Turner Classic Movies crime thriller game of thrones Britbox crossover Christmas television cartoon period drama comics CMT Chernobyl Syfy Comedy Central Rocky TCM stand-up comedy Toys Ovation CBS All Access Countdown Acorn TV Ghostbusters theme song Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Paramount canceled TV shows GLAAD spanish language zombie politics IFC MSNBC talk show CW Seed Tarantino dc Lifetime adventure Apple TV Plus Endgame sitcom spain