TORONTO: "All The King's Men" Misfires

by | September 10, 2006 | Comments

"All The King’s Men" is handsomely mounted. It features a stellar cast. And it’s a misfire from the opening frames. The film, which makes its debut at the Toronto International Film Festival, has all the trappings of an Oscar-bait prestige picture, only without any of the emotional resonance or insight into the politics of its era — or ours. It’s never clear what the movie is trying to say.

For starters, "All The King’s Men" pales in comparison with the 1949 original. That film, based on the novel by Robert Penn Warren (itself loosely based on the career of Huey "The Kingfish" Long) starred Broderick Crawford as Willie Stark, a man who begins his political career as a true-believing populist hell-bent on reclaiming his state from the fatcats before getting drunk on his own power. In contrast, leading man Sean Penn seems like a mad huckster from the outset; his performance is so odd that it hardly seems he will make an active descent into evil — since he acts like he’s already there.

The film shows Stark preaching the populist gospel in the backwaters of Louisiana, much to the consternation of the plutocrats who run the state from behind the scenes. It seems that minutes after taking office, Stark is in danger of being impeached on corruption charges. None of this has any impact, since the movie hasn’t even bothered to explain who Stark is or what he’s done; he’s barely even shown governing.

Jude Law plays Jack Burden, a disillusioned newspaper columnist who decides to join Stark’s cabinet. His motivations are unclear; rather than a man burning with Stark’s idealism, he just seems to be along for the ride. Burton’s strained relationships with childhood friends, played by Kate Winslet and Mark Ruffalo, seem like much ado about nothing, and his betrayal of the man who raised him, played by Anthony Hopkins, resonates so little because their relationship is never fleshed out to begin with. And his longing for Winslet’s character is a non-starter.

What else? In addition to squandering the considerable talents of Penn, Law, Winslet, Hopkins, Ruffalo, Patricia Clarkson, and James Gandolfini, writer/director Steve Zaillian ("A Civil Action," "Searching for Bobby Fisher") bogs the film down with pointless flashbacks; the dialogue is portentous and mannered; and the score resounds with unearned bombast.

Ultimately, "All The King’s Men" never justifies its own existence. We’re never sure what we should think of Willie Stark, we’re not sure what we’re being told about the world of politics, and when there’s already a perfectly good movie called "All The King’s Men," we’re not sure why there’s any need for another.

Tag Cloud

docudrama fast and furious BET Apple Film Lifetime series USA Network indiana jones Certified Fresh classics Valentine's Day YouTube Red zero dark thirty Reality obituary batman The Purge children's TV slashers PlayStation Biopics Mary Poppins Returns romantic comedy Pixar Shondaland Syfy CNN DC Comics Warner Bros. Superheroes SXSW SDCC Apple TV Plus Family BBC America Hallmark First Look Marvel Television sag awards Women's History Month documentaries cancelled medical drama cooking rotten Columbia Pictures comic Trophy Talk 21st Century Fox emmy awards GIFs GLAAD Country spy thriller award winner Premiere Dates Sundance TV Pop Countdown Pop TV President Trivia Holiday Television Critics Association Summer TBS Netflix DGA 4/20 name the review Tarantino Bravo TCA AMC Ovation Holidays foreign what to watch CW Seed finale Crunchyroll Music video on demand Pirates crime Reality Competition south america WarnerMedia APB scary movies TV renewals Sneak Peek satire mission: impossible theme song HBO Go TCA Awards Chernobyl cats crossover TIFF asian-american spider-man Spring TV Captain marvel BBC One boxoffice richard e. Grant twilight Black History Month Comics on TV latino Disney streaming service TCA 2017 Peacock stand-up comedy Paramount Network parents travel Epix hispanic Opinion Martial Arts rotten movies we love Travel Channel hollywood Cannes Drama Spike joker nbcuniversal Kids & Family MCU dogs Turner comics toy story documentary The Witch NYCC Tomatazos witnail comiccon Freeform MSNBC video composers technology Sci-Fi superhero Quiz biography Lionsgate nature Animation Nickelodeon doctor who festivals Awards Tour streaming adaptation Nat Geo Endgame TV strong female leads A&E Discovery Channel BET Awards Awards Infographic best canceled Disney Channel quibi Amazon harry potter game show tv talk TNT green book golden globes facebook Super Bowl TCM anthology Sundance canceled TV shows Walt Disney Pictures Action El Rey teaser book stoner Creative Arts Emmys TLC Photos New York Comic Con IFC Films Watching Series 2016 reviews Election Baby Yoda universal monsters natural history laika movie Trailer adventure Oscars Tumblr mutant animated diversity MTV Adult Swim Mudbound Superheroe Anna Paquin Ghostbusters Best and Worst independent RT21 Comic Book supernatural Chilling Adventures of Sabrina FOX talk show 007 Television Academy Fox News Binge Guide 24 frames Thanksgiving a nightmare on elm street Pet Sematary game of thrones Mary poppins X-Men cops war Star Wars comedies Hulu stop motion Acorn TV FXX Food Network CBS Grammys Paramount cartoon Rom-Com Black Mirror Western reboot sitcom YouTube Premium Teen singing competition revenge ABC Family Tubi 2020 Universal Emmy Nominations PaleyFest Amazon Studios transformers Set visit zombies crime thriller cancelled TV series Rocketman Funimation Arrowverse social media 45 GoT television VH1 dramedy Fantasy 2019 dragons dceu true crime CMT period drama free movies Extras VICE Winter TV OWN VOD Spectrum Originals PBS First Reviews versus Logo discovery Cosplay RT History DC Universe worst all-time mockumentary Disney directors news Dark Horse Comics crime drama The Walking Dead Sundance Now robots romance Box Office screen actors guild Academy Awards unscripted Ellie Kemper Comedy Central Disney+ Disney Plus 2015 Fall TV Amazon Prime Polls and Games Comedy Apple TV+ serial killer Musicals OneApp The CW Video Games ITV Mystery blockbuster cults HBO Max BAFTA christmas movies IFC YA San Diego Comic-Con miniseries kids Horror Netflix Christmas movies sports Disney Plus Cartoon Network movies USA Film Festival WGN Nominations critics Stephen King concert Mindy Kaling 72 Emmy Awards FX Avengers politics 20th Century Fox Esquire elevated horror American Society of Cinematographers BBC Pride Month Writers Guild of America Hallmark Christmas movies anime Starz Calendar Heroines screenings franchise dark Classic Film psychological thriller cancelled TV shows ESPN ABC National Geographic The Arrangement based on movie disaster criterion See It Skip It TV Land Podcast LGBT DirecTV Red Carpet Marathons TruTV Marvel Studios Marvel Christmas psycho Brie Larson indie dc blaxploitation Lucasfilm Toys werewolf ratings Schedule police drama Turner Classic Movies Musical die hard Sony Pictures FX on Hulu cinemax renewed TV shows vampires halloween E! zombie 2017 E3 Song of Ice and Fire ghosts space History Amazon Prime Video Interview Rocky Showtime HBO chucky justice league Lifetime Christmas movies Vudu YouTube casting cars child's play political drama LGBTQ jamie lee curtis spanish language films Winners Mary Tyler Moore 2018 SundanceTV Crackle DC streaming service TCA Winter 2020 Character Guide science fiction Britbox 71st Emmy Awards Rock thriller CBS All Access Emmys Year in Review historical drama NBC sequel aliens Elton John hist Star Trek breaking bad cancelled television binge Hear Us Out Masterpiece Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt spain Shudder spinoff A24