Toronto Film Fest: The Good, The Bad, and The Better So Far

A short roundup of some of the fest's flicks.

by | September 11, 2007 | Comments

Well, it certainly hasn’t been a dull festival. Tons of films big (Michael Clayton) and small (Juno) have screened to kudos, and on the whole there haven’t been very many outright disappointments (notwithstanding George Romero‘s Diary of the Dead and a few others).

It’s now a week into the Toronto Film Festival, and we definitely have our favorites. They include, in no particular order: the Ian Curtis biopic Control, the quirky teen comedy Juno, Lars and the Real Girl starring Ryan Gosling, and Julie Taymor‘s ambitious Beatles-infused Across the Universe. Many other entries are good as well (No Country for Old Men, Michael Clayton, Lust, Caution, Disengagement). A few in particular are unconventionally enjoyable (Sukiyaki Western Django, Nothing is Private).


Across the Universe

I just came from a press screening of Brian DePalma‘s Redacted, anticipation of which stemmed from its second-place showing last week at the Venice Film Festival (where Ang Lee‘s Lust, Caution took the Golden Lion prize). With an unconventional format that combines a French-narrated faux-documentary, a deployed soldier’s home videos, local Arab television reports and fictional video-hosting websites, Redacted tells the (based-on-a-true) story of a group of U.S. Army soldiers involved in the rape and murder of an Iraqi girl. DePalma’s film is at least rife with meaning, though there are so many divisive issues concerning Iraq in Redacted that it’s hard to know where to start. Are U.S. peace-keeping procedures dangerously confusing to Iraqis? Does mutual misunderstanding often lead to tragic civilian casualties? Do the media keep the rest of us adequately informed about a war that is happening on the other side of the world? Redacted is likely to split critics (one journalist warned me off, calling it straight-up “bad,” while a smattering of applause erupted at the end of my screening).

Plenty of other films have gotten mixed receptions as well. Julie Taymor notoriously battled with studio execs over her Across the Universe, which combines a 1960s-1970s love story with historical events, all set to a near non-stop soundtrack of Beatles songs. Sound good to you, fellas? Unsurprisingly, Across the Universe seems to leave many male reviewers cold, while women (and predisposed lovers of musicals) enjoy it much more. The film is out in limited release this week. Full review to come!

Speaking of high profile cinematic gambles, I’m headed out to the late night screening of Todd HaynesI’m Not There. Cate Blanchett nabbed Venice honors for her portrayal of Bob Dylan; six more actors take on different aspects of the legendary musician’s life and persona, including Christian Bale, Heath Ledger, and Richard Gere. More on that very shortly.

Tag Cloud

romantic comedy Marvel Television Spectrum Originals news Adult Swim stoner Superheroes classics Star Wars Fall TV Valentine's Day casting cartoon Martial Arts Tubi Columbia Pictures Epix YouTube Red Mary Poppins Returns festivals rotten movies we love Anna Paquin CNN Year in Review NYCC australia Masterpiece Kids & Family hispanic Freeform Captain marvel Lifetime 24 frames anime mission: impossible cops BET Awards WarnerMedia satire Extras Avengers cars Film cooking historical drama See It Skip It spanish Disney Plus Christmas all-time BET TV renewals Opinion Character Guide Brie Larson Summer Discovery Channel disaster AMC Quiz Amazon Prime cats TBS dc deadpool black scorecard ratings Lionsgate directors CW Seed dramedy Pixar slashers Winter TV TIFF 72 Emmy Awards doctor who Biopics Fox Searchlight SDCC HBO Apple TV+ biography Holiday Netflix Christmas movies composers Certified Fresh sitcom Tumblr Classic Film DGA game of thrones Marathons Spike twilight Baby Yoda 2019 concert spinoff Writers Guild of America chucky ghosts Paramount Network Red Carpet boxoffice Paramount zombie halloween tv GIFs nfl X-Men comics Schedule Acorn TV Sneak Peek independent comic tv talk FOX name the review VOD Shudder USA Showtime fast and furious golden globes DC Universe Black Mirror zero dark thirty comedies Vudu political drama First Look Musicals adaptation streaming TNT quibi Peacock binge Interview singing competition ABC Family VH1 crime hollywood Thanksgiving American Society of Cinematographers A&E ABC award winner christmas movies San Diego Comic-Con a nightmare on elm street versus Grammys Disney Channel series Star Trek unscripted rotten TCA 2017 Emmy Nominations Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt History social media RT21 DirecTV spanish language FXX Mary poppins Cosplay GLAAD The Academy Box Office strong female leads Cannes Crackle Super Bowl Hallmark Christmas movies Turner Classic Movies Marvel canceled DC Comics Creative Arts Emmys Amazon Podcast FX on Hulu Mary Tyler Moore 2015 reviews best TCA Awards National Geographic cancelled crime drama joker werewolf Reality Competition toronto nbcuniversal HBO Max thriller Rocketman Toys cancelled TV shows Shondaland venice war Fox News movie obituary Calendar Hallmark El Rey Animation Nickelodeon SundanceTV Sundance Now Disney streaming service toy story Photos Travel Channel rt archives TV Land PaleyFest Mystery stop motion mockumentary MTV Fantasy Television Critics Association period drama politics Women's History Month psychological thriller witnail reboot TCA Winter 2020 2016 E3 mutant The CW nature sports blaxploitation Amazon Studios screen actors guild TCM Horror what to watch theme song YouTube science fiction OneApp DC streaming service Trailer game show dragons Pop TV MSNBC 007 Stephen King emmy awards Emmys Comic Book comic books Binge Guide Bravo Lifetime Christmas movies CMT finale technology aliens Rom-Com Trivia TLC Hear Us Out harry potter Ghostbusters documentary documentaries A24 Turner Britbox cults Drama RT History Chernobyl GoT vampires Comics on TV FX italian video 4/20 cinemax adventure Watching Series President Crunchyroll Winners scary movies Comedy Central animated Music kids New York Comic Con Dark Horse Comics Election richard e. Grant BBC One batman sag awards The Purge Oscars book cancelled TV series Chilling Adventures of Sabrina PBS Premiere Dates Disney halloween dceu video on demand comiccon asian-american 2020 Esquire BBC America transformers blockbuster talk show YA Arrowverse worst movies universal monsters superhero Song of Ice and Fire Reality SXSW sequel TruTV child's play parents stand-up comedy japanese Teen Syfy Walt Disney Pictures Ovation Action ESPN Mudbound laika Pirates justice league dogs crossover jamie lee curtis Apple TV Plus PlayStation NBC Countdown worst Tarantino ID foreign criterion 45 psycho Superheroe CBS green book indie VICE dark teaser Infographic Endgame revenge remakes LGBTQ Pet Sematary die hard Marvel Studios spy thriller Comedy television free movies breaking bad natural history miniseries anthology 71st Emmy Awards Starz Rock zombies Television Academy WGN BBC Netflix Logo french ITV Black History Month franchise critics Holidays CBS All Access Apple Video Games docudrama facebook Elton John Cartoon Network Warner Bros. Trophy Talk E! movies Universal diversity robots Nat Geo Awards Tour based on movie Polls and Games south america sequels Mindy Kaling Family Awards Heroines BAFTA First Reviews Country screenings IFC Films Academy Awards james bond serial killer Sony Pictures spider-man Sundance archives football APB LGBT Best and Worst Pop police drama children's TV Funimation Sci-Fi Musical Western 21st Century Fox YouTube Premium Nominations hist The Witch Disney+ Disney Plus 2018 Spring TV elevated horror Rocky The Walking Dead renewed TV shows 2017 festival 20th Century Fox HBO Go Amazon Prime Video MCU discovery Set visit romance Tomatazos Ellie Kemper TCA Film Festival latino canceled TV shows USA Network medical drama films Sundance TV spain cancelled television The Arrangement supernatural crime thriller Hulu Pride Month indiana jones space travel TV OWN Food Network Lucasfilm true crime IFC