News

Trilogies With One Director Are Fresher Than Those With Multiple Helmers

Consistency is key, according to our John Wick-inspired Tomatometer deep dive.

by | May 31, 2019 | Comments

John Wick: Chapter 3 - Parabellum
(Photo by Lionsgate)

Do movie trilogies have Fresher Tomatometer scores and make more money at the box office when one director (or co-directors) oversees all three films? Or, is it better if three different directors each tackle different films in a trilogy? With the wildly successful John Wick: Chapter 3 – Parabellum marking the third Certified Fresh John Wick collaboration between director Chad Stahelski and Keanu Reeves (with a fourth on the way!), we decided to do a Tomatometer deep dive into theatrically released trilogies helmed by single directors. We wanted to know how the Tomatometer scores and domestic box office numbers for trilogies like Francis Ford Coppola’s The Godfather, Jay Roach’s Austin Powers, and The Wachowskis’ Matrix films compare to trilogies directed by two or three separate directors.

Is consistency actually key?

After comparing the Tomatometer and box office data of 83 different trilogies we learned that when one person (or a duo like the Wachowskis) directs all three films, their trilogies make more money on average and have much higher Tomatometer averages than the trilogies in which two or three different people direct the entries. There are exceptions to the rule, of course, but the numbers favor The Dark Knight, Spider-Man, and Back to the Future trilogies, which were lucky enough to have Christopher Nolan, Sam Raimi, and Robert Zemeckis see them all the way through.

If you’re interested in reading about the trilogy selection process, and seeing the list of selected franchises, you can check them out below. Also, we know Stahelski co-directed John Wick with David Leitch, but Stahelski stayed around to helm the second and third installments when Leitch moved on to direct Atomic Blonde and Deadpool 2; since he has been on the project the entire time, we’re considering him to be “one” director.

Here is the data – and the trends we found.


The Fewer the Names, the better the trilogy 

THE LORD OF THE RINGS: THE RETURN OF THE KING, Viggo Mortensen, 2003, (c) New Line/courtesy Everett Collection
(Photo by © New Line/courtesy Everett Collection)
  • Average Tomatometer for trilogies directed by one person: 68%
  • Average Tomatometer for trilogies directed by two directors: 54%
  • Average Tomatometer for trilogies directed by three directors: 49%

Based on the Tomatometer averages, it’s clear that having one person (or team) direct a trilogy is the way to go for Freshness. The 68% Tomatometer average for trilogies with a single director or directing team isn’t super Fresh, but it’s well ahead of the 54% and 49% averages of the trilogies with multiple directors. The Fresh average can be attributed to exceptional franchises such as Richard Linklater’s Before trilogy (97.6% average Tomatometer score), How to Train Your Dragon (94.6%), and The Lord of the Rings (93%), trilogies that received multiple Academy Awards and include no films with Tomatometer scores lower than 91%. Another factor that sets the single director category apart is that 22 of the 34 total trilogies in this category (64.7%) are Fresh, whereas only 14 (56%) and six (24%) of the trilogies in the other two categories have Fresh scores.


All Trilogies Drop Off In Quality, But A Single Director Will Help you Stay (Just) Fresh In the End.

Spider-Man 3
(Photo by © Sony Pictures/courtesy Everett Collection)
  • Tomatometer averages of the first, second, and third films in trilogies directed by one person or team: 75.5%, 68%, 60.8%
  • Tomatometer averages of the first, second, and third films in trilogies directed by two people: 71%, 47%, 45%
  • Tomatometer averages of the first, second, and third films in trilogies directed by three people: 71.4%, 46.3%, 35.5%

The first, second, and third films in trilogies directed by one person or team all have Fresh Tomatometer averages (75.5%, 68%, 60.8%), and the 7.5% Tomatometer drop-off between the first and second film is pretty solid when compared to the 24% and 25.1% drops when it comes to trilogies with two and three directors, respectively. The sequels that contributed to the Fresh Tomatometer averages throughout the series are classics like John Wick: Chapter 2 (89%), Evil Dead 2 (98%), Spider-Man 2 (93%), Before Midnight (98%), The Dark Knight (94%), The Trip to Spain (82%), and The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King (93%). The coolest (or nerdiest) fact here is how similar the Tomatometer averages for the trilogies directed by two or three people are until their third films (45% compared with 35.5%). The Tomatometer dropoff for trilogies with three directors was caused by soul-crushers such as Robocop 3 (3%), The Bad News Bears Go to Japan (0%), and Crocodile Dundee in Los Angeles (11%).


More Directors Equals Less Money (Most of the Time)

Iron Man
(Photo by © Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures)
  • Trilogies directed by one person or team: $782 million domestic box office average (adjusted for inflation)
  • Trilogies directed by two people: $631 million domestic box office average
  • Trilogies directed by three people: $461 million domestic box office average

The $782 million total domestic average for trilogies directed by a single person would make any studio executive happy — and probably get them ordering another trilogy ASAP. It helps that eight of the 36 (22.8%) series with a single director or directing team, including the Star Wars prequels and The Hobbit trilogy, made over $1 billion domestically after adjusting for inflation. The $631 and $461 million box office averages for the other groups of trilogies are very respectable. However, only six of the 58 trilogies (10.3%) in the other two categories made over $1 billion domestically; these multi-director trilogies include Iron Man, Beverly Hills Cop, and the original Star Wars trilogy. The newest Star Wars trilogy will likely join their ranks.

  • Domestic box office averages (adjusted for inflation) of the first, second, and third films in trilogies directed by one person or team: $301 million, $266 million, $210 million
  • Domestic box office averages of the first, second, and third films in trilogies directed by two people or teams: $278 million, $206 million, $145 million
  • Domestic box office averages of the first, second, and third films in trilogies directed by three people or teams: $228 million, $147 million, $92 million

The standout trend here is that the box office averages for the movies directed by one person or team all stayed above $200 million – the majority of the first film’s audience kept coming back for more. Trilogies directed by one person also had the smallest box office drop between each film; the $91 million (30%) box office drop from the first to third film is smaller than the $125 (45%) and $136 (60%) million drops for trilogies with two directors and three directors, respectfully.


ARE THERE EXCEPTIONS TO THE RULE?

Quantrell D. Colbert/Universal Pictures
(Photo by Quantrell D. Colbert/Universal Pictures)

Of course, when it comes to Tomatometer ratings, the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) has proven with their Iron Man (two directors), Thor (three directors), and Captain America (one single director and a directing team) trilogies that it sometimes doesn’t matter how many directors helm the movies. Also, the Pitch Perfect, Hannibal, Star Trek (2009-2016), Meet the Parents, X-Men, Beverly Hills Cop, and Wolverine trilogies pulled in huge amounts of money and had multiple directors. So, trilogies can absolutely work with multiple directors. 


HOW DID WE PICK THE TRILOGIES?

John Wick: Chapter 3 - Parabellum
(Photo by Lionsgate)

Since John Wick tells the continuing story of Keanu Reeves’s titular assassin killing hundreds of henchmen on his quest for revenge, we stuck with trilogies that told a continuous story featuring the same character(s) or plot lines throughout three films. Examples are Richard Linklater’s Before trilogy, and Todd Phillips’ Hangover trilogy, which saw the exploits of the same characters to a conclusion. We didn’t include trilogies with loose-connections (Noriko Trilogy), similar themes (Three Colors), or actors (Cornetto Trilogy) tying them all together. Also, you may notice that some of the trilogies we included such as the Pirates of the Caribbean, Jason Bourne, Jurassic Park, and Scream franchises went on to have more than three films. We included them because they had three-film narrative arcs that were completed with the third installment (e.g., Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade). Some of these films had fourth (or fifth or sixth installments), but most of these later installments were meant to be part of a new trilogy (e.g. Jurassic World and Scream 4, which was supposed to be the beginning of a new trilogy). If a trilogy did not have complete Tomatometer scores they weren’t included. That’s why you won’t see the Infernal Affairs or Samurai trilogies below. The trilogies also needed to have been released in theaters. We didn’t include series that completed their trilogies with direct-to-DVD releases .

Number of Trilogies directed by three people/teams – 25: Alien (1979-1992), The Bad News Bears, Beverly Hills Cop, Blade, Blair Witch, Child’s Play (1988-1991), Crocodile Dundee, The Expendables, Free Willy, Friday, Hannibal, Harold & Kumar, In the Heat of the Night, Johnny English, The Mighty Ducks, Oh God!, Omen, Pitch Perfect, The Ring, Robocop, Rugrats, Star Wars (1977-1983), Thor, Transporter, xXx

Number of Trilogies directed by two people – 24: 50 Shades of Grey, Bridget Jones Diary, Captain America, Cars, The Chronicles of Narnia, The Creature From the Black Lagoon, Divergent, Iron Man, Jason Bourne (2002-2007), Jurassic Park (1993-2001), Kung Fu Panda, Look Who’s Talking, Major League, Meet the Parents, The Mummy, Naked Gun, Poltergeist, Porky’s, Rise of the Planet of the Apes, The Santa Clause, Smokey and the Bandit, Star Trek, Taken, Wolverine (2009-2017), X-Men (2000-2006)

Number of Trilogies directed by one person – 34: Austin Powers, Back to the Future, Before Trilogy, Da Vinci Code, The Dark Knight, Despicable Me, Evil Dead, The Godfather, Hangover, The Hobbit, Hotel Transylvania, How to Train Your Dragon, Indiana Jones (1981-1989), Jackass, John Wick, The Lord of the Rings, Madagascar, Mad Max (1979-1985), Matrix, Maze Runner, Men in Black, The Mexico Trilogy, Night at the Museum, Ocean’s Trilogy, Pirates of the Caribbean (2003-2007), Purge, Riddick, Rush Hour, Scream (1996-2000), Spider-Man, Star Wars Prequels, The Trip, Unbreakable

Note: All Tomatometer data is accurate as of May 29, 2019


Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

TCM Character Guide Disney Plus elevated horror Esquire Creative Arts Emmys biography Musicals die hard Emmys TV Land Christmas Britbox Amazon ratings Trailer Musical BBC America natural history Women's History Month versus Columbia Pictures cats Apple TV Plus parents critics Pop The CW zombies Spike Peacock crime drama Sony Pictures Crackle true crime Academy Awards movie films hist book Baby Yoda justice league war witnail YA 4/20 Sci-Fi 2019 APB spinoff Brie Larson all-time blockbuster diversity 2015 TCA 2017 anthology Freeform zombie OWN discovery BET tv talk Quiz Holidays VOD richard e. Grant blaxploitation Tarantino ABC Mystery Fantasy Turner Classic Movies Martial Arts Box Office Video Games DGA Trivia USA Network Interview CBS All Access Food Network sag awards reboot Dark Horse Comics slashers YouTube Premium vampires Watching Series Grammys PlayStation Certified Fresh cancelled TV series Ghostbusters Apple unscripted LGBTQ DC streaming service Paramount Network cars Shondaland name the review robots political drama History Music Adult Swim Tomatazos ABC Family medical drama Sundance Now Schedule Apple TV+ First Look Superheroe Starz casting Red Carpet Kids & Family hispanic anime crossover christmas movies talk show Amazon Prime Video cancelled television documentaries disaster BAFTA LGBT Star Trek joker historical drama Classic Film 24 frames Thanksgiving cults supernatural nature AMC latino period drama Television Academy game show Oscars GLAAD The Walking Dead HBO Max breaking bad Ellie Kemper reviews toy story 2017 cooking DC Universe serial killer thriller game of thrones Superheroes halloween Disney Channel Infographic spain Emmy Nominations video on demand President Funimation Extras crime asian-american WGN BET Awards composers Warner Bros. Showtime Sundance TV Hallmark Christmas movies Trophy Talk The Witch Disney Reality Competition psycho mutant Writers Guild of America indie mockumentary SundanceTV independent Pop TV Fall TV FOX 2016 docudrama Mindy Kaling batman USA Western Photos Winter TV Cartoon Network HBO Go Premiere Dates Spectrum Originals Netflix Christmas movies IFC dogs Marathons See It Skip It theme song zero dark thirty Hear Us Out Bravo IFC Films animated Pet Sematary GIFs Reality Sundance Black History Month what to watch golden globes FX on Hulu YouTube Crunchyroll CMT miniseries Opinion San Diego Comic-Con twilight Heroines NBC Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt child's play Lifetime Christmas movies TV renewals E3 Rocky Awards Tour Comic Book DirecTV children's TV YouTube Red 21st Century Fox E! free movies TIFF canceled TV shows Rocketman dark Song of Ice and Fire Lifetime Drama Hallmark dragons Toys screen actors guild 45 Paramount Netflix doctor who romance crime thriller Binge Guide Amazon Prime travel Action foreign Arrowverse best teaser documentary Lionsgate scary movies dc MSNBC green book SDCC spider-man Film Festival Tubi Nickelodeon police drama VH1 Masterpiece sequel psychological thriller Disney+ Disney Plus spanish language Marvel Studios Sneak Peek dramedy stoner adaptation OneApp franchise TCA Turner 2018 RT21 science fiction Election sports ghosts kids stand-up comedy 2020 singing competition 71st Emmy Awards television comics sitcom movies Acorn TV ESPN cancelled TV shows comiccon directors Film TCA Winter 2020 Spring TV Chilling Adventures of Sabrina VICE Mary Tyler Moore Anna Paquin Star Wars series Epix Holiday Countdown quibi binge Lucasfilm RT History award winner Syfy TV MTV video Walt Disney Pictures Awards cops Nat Geo Pride Month romantic comedy CBS Family BBC One Stephen King A24 First Reviews Tumblr DC Comics chucky Calendar festivals HBO screenings boxoffice The Arrangement 20th Century Fox renewed TV shows TruTV Cannes south america Pixar FXX aliens A&E Best and Worst Chernobyl Elton John based on movie strong female leads Pirates social media New York Comic Con CW Seed adventure Marvel universal monsters canceled The Purge WarnerMedia Vudu Valentine's Day Fox News Ovation Cosplay Logo Summer FX PBS dceu BBC TLC mission: impossible Animation TNT Disney streaming service space MCU spy thriller werewolf satire news cinemax Mudbound 007 Black Mirror Winners Amazon Studios streaming CNN Nominations NYCC finale Year in Review technology National Geographic ITV revenge Marvel Television TBS Polls and Games Rom-Com Mary poppins SXSW Discovery Channel Horror concert Avengers El Rey Endgame cancelled X-Men harry potter PaleyFest Rock Set visit criterion Shudder facebook politics American Society of Cinematographers Podcast rotten movies we love Teen Comics on TV Travel Channel cartoon comedies Country GoT transformers Biopics indiana jones Captain marvel a nightmare on elm street Super Bowl jamie lee curtis Hulu Comedy Central Comedy Universal comic Mary Poppins Returns