UK Critics Consensus: The Day The Earth Stood Still, Still Stinks

Plus, Inkheart Is Fantastic Fantasy

by | December 12, 2008 | Comments

With Christmas looming large, and no Potter on the schedule, we have two fantasy flicks in the UK cinemas jostling for your hard-earned galleons. We have sci-fi remake The Day The Earth Stood Still starring Keanu Reeves and Jennifer Connelly, and fantasy literary adaptation Inkheart, starring Paul Bettany and Brendan Fraser. But are either worth parting with your Christmas cash to see? This is what the British critics had to say…

The original Day The Earth Stood Still from 1951 is a bona-fide sci-fi classic, and tells the story of extra-terrestrial visitor Klaatu, who comes to Earth with a message of goodwill, accompanied by Gort, a large laser-sporting robot. When a film of this stature gets lined up for a remake, you have to ask yourself…why? Why don’t studios remake films that weren’t very good the first time round, instead of trying to repackage a film, so of its time, that will only be compared unfavourably to the original?

With the UK critics largely dismissing the film, for its lazy CGI, uninspiring performances and shoe-horned eco-warning message, they are all also asking… Why bother? Tim Robey of the Independent summed up the general consensus by saying “the cinematography is dismal, and the cocktail of lazy CGI and po-faced, sub-Al-Gore environment lecture leaves you light-headed with tedium.” The Day The Earth Stood Still is currently languishing at 24% on the Tomatometer. Klaatu Barada Rotten.

Inkheart is closer in tone to the Potter-esque fantasy that is missing from our winter schedule this year. Based on a hugely popular German childrens’ novel by Cornelia Funke, Inkheart stars Brendan Fraser as Mo, a man who discovers he has the power to bring literary characters to life by reading books aloud, whose daughter Meggie, knows nothing of her father’s bizarre and powerful talent.

Ably supported by some of the UK’s finest acting talents including Paul Bettany, Jim Broadbent, Andy Serkis and Helen Mirren, the critics gave Inkheart their blessing for its cheerful nature, praising the actors for their dependable turns with Daniel Etherington of Channel 4 films calling it “Solid fantasy fare, nicely performed and handsomely made.” With the US critics response not yet counted, the film stands at a healthy 73% on the Tomatometer. Check back on the 23rd of January in the new year to see what the US critics thought of Inkheart.

Quote Of The Week

“Not only is it 20th Century Fox’s first ‘carbon neutral’ production but its Earth-destroying special effects have less impact than a fart in a thunderstorm.”

The Day The Earth Stood Still. Larushka Ivan-Zadeh.

Tag Cloud

Sundance TV Opinion OWN Arrowverse Mary poppins Rom-Com slashers franchise New York Comic Con ABC Family spain ratings Set visit biography Rock Chernobyl travel Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Podcast NYCC VICE LGBTQ Film Festival strong female leads Spectrum Originals Country aliens kids Box Office LGBT Musicals Apple TV Plus directors Disney+ Disney Plus discovery Toys Marvel Mary Tyler Moore Walt Disney Pictures The Witch Disney Plus TIFF spider-man quibi VOD YouTube scary movies Interview 20th Century Fox E! parents Writers Guild of America Tumblr Syfy Food Network Disney Channel crime thriller Masterpiece comiccon Oscars richard e. Grant Amazon Prime Black History Month WGN renewed TV shows joker political drama MCU A24 crime Nat Geo teaser Disney streaming service CMT IFC Films book casting Year in Review Heroines hist BBC christmas movies Cosplay 2018 diversity Schedule Awards concert toy story Comedy Central El Rey First Reviews werewolf psychological thriller satire adaptation Calendar elevated horror all-time stand-up comedy Red Carpet Pet Sematary cops docudrama E3 Reality Competition Mindy Kaling unscripted Ellie Kemper revenge Freeform a nightmare on elm street TLC SundanceTV TBS thriller doctor who Ovation best Turner 2020 dceu Marvel Television cancelled AMC PlayStation vampires tv talk ghosts USA Sneak Peek series witnail Pop canceled TV shows children's TV animated mission: impossible 4/20 Family Hallmark Christmas movies Holiday video on demand Trivia disaster Polls and Games Super Bowl screenings Rocketman Winter TV transformers cars Nickelodeon Columbia Pictures comic festivals VH1 Sundance Emmys BBC America universal monsters comedies dramedy Spike NBC Discovery Channel Binge Guide Apple RT History Cannes Biopics X-Men technology HBO Max serial killer Bravo Pop TV critics anthology harry potter Lucasfilm GIFs Musical streaming Song of Ice and Fire Countdown chucky Holidays Drama ABC boxoffice facebook Infographic Sci-Fi GoT Pirates Marvel Studios what to watch dragons Best and Worst hispanic police drama Anna Paquin SXSW Classic Film cooking sag awards Academy Awards Star Wars robots PaleyFest versus Black Mirror The Arrangement finale Amazon Studios Tarantino TNT television BET Trophy Talk Dark Horse Comics dc FXX crossover mutant MTV reviews Baby Yoda 2019 stoner sports war science fiction Hear Us Out Nominations TCA Winter 2020 2016 PBS golden globes Premiere Dates Lifetime movies The Walking Dead Travel Channel documentaries IFC Extras news Peacock adventure Brie Larson Disney Film The Purge Summer TV renewals spanish language breaking bad Avengers zombies justice league Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt American Society of Cinematographers Martial Arts Trailer name the review Showtime spy thriller Women's History Month asian-american Kids & Family 71st Emmy Awards Universal YouTube Premium twilight TV DirecTV Comic Book Marathons YA Fall TV dogs HBO Go Pride Month halloween TruTV independent foreign Teen Superheroes BET Awards based on movie Logo true crime Pixar Spring TV HBO indie cancelled TV shows 45 talk show Action Sony Pictures Tubi RT21 Acorn TV Adult Swim theme song screen actors guild Certified Fresh Photos WarnerMedia game show cancelled TV series Video Games Lifetime Christmas movies binge cancelled television Winners CBS Vudu History Amazon comics award winner Endgame south america Ghostbusters Western films Epix Esquire 2017 The CW Valentine's Day Hulu Election game of thrones free movies Horror video jamie lee curtis Hallmark sitcom Shondaland Star Trek documentary Awards Tour Paramount Mary Poppins Returns Netflix period drama National Geographic romance cults criterion rotten movies we love anime MSNBC Rocky Grammys DGA canceled DC Universe CBS All Access zombie green book blaxploitation Thanksgiving spinoff APB Christmas Music OneApp Turner Classic Movies Sundance Now mockumentary TCA 2017 24 frames cats romantic comedy CNN Starz CW Seed First Look blockbuster die hard 007 President GLAAD Captain marvel miniseries FOX See It Skip It Comedy Apple TV+ zero dark thirty Animation Shudder composers nature Comics on TV TCM space sequel Cartoon Network batman DC streaming service social media YouTube Red Quiz San Diego Comic-Con crime drama Character Guide Emmy Nominations supernatural medical drama politics historical drama Paramount Network FX on Hulu Reality 21st Century Fox Funimation Britbox child's play ITV Fantasy 2015 Warner Bros. A&E DC Comics USA Network Mystery Crackle SDCC psycho indiana jones cartoon Elton John movie cinemax Television Academy reboot Superheroe singing competition latino Watching Series Netflix Christmas movies FX Mudbound ESPN Lionsgate Crunchyroll Amazon Prime Video Tomatazos Fox News Creative Arts Emmys BBC One Stephen King TCA natural history dark BAFTA TV Land