Showdowns

RT Fans Crown Halloween the Ultimate Horror Movie

The John Carpenter classic surged from behind on the last day of voting to eke out a victory over The Shining by a mere 20 votes!

by | October 29, 2021 | Comments

(Click to enlarge.)

After six intense rounds of voting on some of the most beloved, most iconic horror films ever, we can finally announce that the winner of the Ultimate Horror Movie Showdown is John Carpenter’s original Halloween! And, appropriately enough, the win came by the narrowest of margins, making it the closest battle of the entire tournament. Stanley Kubrick’s adaptation of Stephen King’s The Shining held a tenuous lead of just under 100 votes as the last day of voting began, but as afternoon came, the tide began to turn. When all was said and done, almost 14,000 votes were cast, and Halloween received a last-minute surge that helped it eke out the victory over The Shining by a mere 20 votes (6917 to 6897, to be exact)!

As always, thanks to everyone who participated and followed along, leaving comments and discussing the results. If nothing else, we hope we’ve reminded you of a few forgotten favorites or a few gems you’ve been meaning to check out that you can place on your Halloween watch list for the weekend. With that said, stay tuned for our next showdown, and have a safe and Happy Halloween!

Round 1 Results | Round 2 Results | Round 3 Results | Round 4 Results | Round 5 Results


Final Round Result

Round 1 Results | Round 2 Results | Round 3 Results | Round 4 Results | Round 5 Results


On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 Next

Tag Cloud

Walt Disney Pictures Columbia Pictures rotten dragons FX on Hulu Academy Awards BAFTA mutant Pop Wes Anderson documentary venice Endgame japanese Showtime TBS Britbox Instagram Live Crackle aapi TV renewals free movies kong DirecTV Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt new star wars movies cults Captain marvel natural history spinoff Mudbound Superheroes A24 young adult TCM Turner Classic Movies video marvel comics batman Countdown CBS spanish TV movies Winter TV TV One Extras ABC Image Comics 24 frames scorecard trailers diversity zombie comic book movie mcc Comedy See It Skip It Musicals TCA Awards versus boxing anthology spy thriller IFC Films YouTube Red Hear Us Out animated saw The Witch fresh robots LGBT 93rd Oscars Tumblr reboot Tomatazos football NYCC A&E 2016 DC Comics SXSW IFC Netflix Christmas movies PBS The Purge Masterpiece Premiere Dates indie Sony Pictures 90s dogs rom-coms adaptation Polls and Games PlayStation posters Sneak Peek Neflix Freeform book adaptation festival Trivia Lifetime Awards Tour crossover south america rt labs critics edition twilight indiana jones fast and furious Apple TV Plus YouTube Premium LGBTQ TV Land Hallmark video on demand Nat Geo President Pirates 4/20 vs. Pop TV NBA cancelled black OneApp Exclusive Video comic technology GIFs Paramount discovery Turner Marvel Studios PaleyFest stop motion crime drama halloween tv feel good National Geographic IMDb TV zombies slashers transformers YA women hollywood politics rotten movies we love name the review movies telelvision international sports criterion child's play sag awards king arthur Lucasfilm Creative Arts Emmys spain ghosts japan CBS All Access Classic Film high school tv talk Apple TV+ adventure book HBO Max Avengers Mystery james bond comic book movies 45 werewolf satire Television Critics Association action-comedy zero dark thirty TLC basketball 2018 Song of Ice and Fire Dark Horse Comics facebook Comic-Con@Home 2021 Spike NBC ABC Signature Amazon mission: impossible sopranos WarnerMedia wonder woman blockbuster scary cops witnail CW Seed golden globes TIFF new york Infographic Hallmark Christmas movies Marvel First Reviews comic books San Diego Comic-Con 99% theme song Apple Vudu christmas movies canceled TV shows dceu Sci-Fi USA teaser Country gangster MCU space Year in Review 71st Emmy Awards obituary GLAAD E! remakes Amazon Prime Video Paramount Network directors quibi Awards Broadway Western travel screen actors guild Watching Series MSNBC Cartoon Network dreamworks Marvel Television Fox News cooking war TCA children's TV OWN latino true crime based on movie Alien Stephen King Schedule SDCC razzies Binge Guide 2019 Certified Fresh Travel Channel ViacomCBS ABC Family breaking bad foreign New York Comic Con Film Holidays dramedy Syfy Horror miniseries Musical archives docuseries composers Christmas art house AMC toronto HBO History nature The Academy police drama Cosplay a nightmare on elm street 1990s thriller Shudder kaiju 2021 Super Bowl Arrowverse live event Film Festival joker hidden camera doctor who Pride Month The Walking Dead Drama 2015 Warner Bros. political drama anime VICE 72 Emmy Awards Family TruTV festivals deadpool ID blockbusters australia kids Mindy Kaling superhero suspense Comedy Central cancelled TV shows slasher live action lord of the rings RT21 GoT Spectrum Originals jurassic park Winners marvel cinematic universe emmy awards revenge franchise universal monsters CMT Baby Yoda Pacific Islander Legendary comiccon period drama biopic mob Disney+ Disney Plus Disney Plus spanish language APB Crunchyroll black comedy Video Games spider-man cartoon Reality Competition Marathons Netflix Pixar Rocketman historical drama medical drama VH1 20th Century Fox worst rt archives Biopics Photos Calendar Trophy Talk Sundance films Lionsgate SundanceTV Best and Worst Trailer Epix Universal Grammys game of thrones elevated horror spider-verse Chilling Adventures of Sabrina aliens genre Anna Paquin The CW DGA First Look vampires debate Emmy Nominations AMC Plus 73rd Emmy Awards USA Network concert dc Character Guide Women's History Month series Hulu heist movie worst movies Opinion rt labs The Walt Disney Company WGN Shondaland sequels FX ratings best screenings RT History American Society of Cinematographers Logo Comics on TV psycho Rom-Com movie independent Toys Pet Sematary Amazon Prime green book popular reviews streaming movies legend Bravo comedies critic resources cars Superheroe Martial Arts what to watch disaster YouTube hist psychological thriller 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Star Wars Mary Poppins Returns Tarantino Sundance Now toy story Spring TV Fall TV 2017 cancelled TV series Quiz Summer Food Network serial killer asian-american hispanic heritage month BBC One The Arrangement FXX comics Election Emmys Red Carpet halloween Universal Pictures Oscars BBC Thanksgiving nbcuniversal Chernobyl Tokyo Olympics Rocky DC streaming service biography prank italian science fiction target cats Mary poppins Tubi game show know your critic adenture cancelled television stoner Black Mirror 21st Century Fox Esquire french BBC America Rock 007 chucky Television Academy DC Universe critics BET Awards FOX E3 crime Star Trek Paramount Plus streaming scene in color Mary Tyler Moore Reality Podcast godzilla Animation casting pirates of the caribbean Teen dexter Amazon Studios Disney streaming service Sundance TV TCA 2017 king kong Nickelodeon Fox Searchlight Action mockumentary social media Holiday El Rey Box Office olympics Peacock canceled Disney Channel scary movies blaxploitation documentaries VOD Valentine's Day hispanic cinemax richard e. Grant ESPN Ghostbusters harry potter CNN Interview Adult Swim renewed TV shows ITV Discovery Channel superman Heroines boxoffice Ovation Kids & Family golden globe awards TV Disney news Elton John MTV Ellie Kemper dark die hard Acorn TV talk show Fantasy Lifetime Christmas movies HBO Go justice league Black History Month classics Starz unscripted Set visit 2020 monster movies jamie lee curtis parents crime thriller Brie Larson docudrama television Nominations all-time Cannes singing competition stand-up comedy Writers Guild of America sequel BET nfl X-Men TCA Winter 2020 new zealand Comic Book binge romance Music strong female leads finale royal family sitcom romantic comedy supernatural award winner Funimation TNT laika