Watching Series: The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King

We Revisit The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings Movies

by , and | December 12, 2014 | Comments

 In anticipation of the upcoming release of Peter Jackson’s The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies, we here at RT decided to take a look back at the Lord of the Rings trilogy and the first two films of the Hobbittrilogy. Our latest installment covers The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug, which editors Tim Ryan and Ryan Fujitani rewatched for some fresh perspective.

The Fellowship of the Ring | The Two Towers The Return of the King

An Unexpected Journey | The Desolation of Smaug


The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King

Luke: I know some of us balked at the notion of an extended Return of the King — wasn’t the theatrical cut, with its endless endings (in the book, by the way) enough? Well I was pleasantly surprised by this one. Unlike the Two Towers, and even more than Fellowship, I ate up every extended moment in the longer Return of the King. In fact, not only would I say it’s my new favorite, it also — finally — elevated everything to that rousing level that I thought had been missing before. One thing I loved about the books was the feeling of dread that ran through the story, the idea that the world was ephemeral and about to be swallowed up by darkness at any moment. Return of the King captured that for me; it was like a series of climaxes where everyone’s fate was balancing on the precipice. And everything comes into its own here, too — visually, Jackson is less indebted to the “Spielberg face” and finds his own classical groove, and the characters (even Merry and Pippin, who bordered on annoying for me at earlier points) all pull their weight.

Tim: I totally agree. The first two chapters are undoubtedly visually masterful, and the story is propulsive, but I found the characters to be archetypes rather than great characters — sturdy archetypes, to be sure, but more defined by their quest than by distinctive personalities or emotional weight. However, The Return of the King is where the trilogy finally achieves the magisterial power I’d been waiting for. It’s able to juggle its multiple plot strands with greater ease; the characters feel more fleshed out, and there’s an apocalyptic urgency to just about everything, from Frodo’s precarious climb to Aragorn’s tense meeting with the King of the Dead (for me, the scene where Aragorn, Legolas, and Gimli escape from an avalanche of skulls is one of my favorites in a franchise overstuffed with astonishing set pieces — it’s the type of nightmarish threat that would make Indiana Jones wake up in a cold sweat).



Ryan: Tim, you took the words right out of my mouth regarding the scene where Aragorn and Co. confront the undead army. That entire sequence, though relatively short, is one of my favorites. In fact, the first half of Return of the King had me well engaged, what with its “rally the troops” vibe; it’s one of those common filmic themes that tend to excite me.

Having said that, though, I might disagree with your assertion that the film did a better job of balancing the various story threads, especially in the extended version; the film does cut back and forth between Gandalf at Minas Tirith and the forces of Rohan pretty effectively, but during the long middle stretch, Sam and Frodo are only visited sporadically. In fact, it seemed as though the quest to destroy the ring was far less important here than the large scale battles being fought elsewhere. The difference, at least for me, was that, while I found Sam and Frodo’s journey with Gollum the most compelling in the previous film, they were decidedly much less interesting in this one, so I didn’t mind that they disappeared from the story for long stretches. Plus, there were so many great moments peppered throughout that I remained wholly engaged.

Luke: Maybe that’s because Frodo was unconscious for a lot of it? I see what you’re saying though. I don’t think the quest to destroy the Ring was any less interesting for me, it’s just that everything else rose to the same level of engagement. Events here were just so much more vivid to me. (Granted, I was awake this time, too). Like, when Denethor asks Pippin to sing, and the melancholy hobbit ballad, set against scenes of battle, is intercut with those wonderful closeups of Denethor crunching and slurping on his food. The way Jackson shoots the Nazgûl (some excellent blood-curdling sound design work, by the way) against the ashen skies. Or one of my favorite mini-moments — when Sauron’s grisly emissary greets the heroes at the gate, and Aragorn cocks his head quizzically at the sight of the creature’s grotesque mouth and voice — a great, subtle bit of playing from Viggo Mortensen. Also, credit where it’s due: Has anyone given a more compelling monotone performance than Orlando Bloom here?



Ryan: Well, considering his role up to now has primarily consisted of firing arrows and periodically uttering vaguely ominous lines like, “A red sun rises. Blood has been spilled this night,” sure, I’ll grant you that. By the way, the scene with Sauron’s emissary at the gates of Mordor was cut from the theatrical version, and it’s actually one of the choices I agreed with. It wasn’t bad, but it also wasn’t necessary, and I might argue that the bizarrely comical quality of his twitchy smile felt a little out of place in that moment.

Luke: Oh, I didn’t realize that. It was indeed comical, I guess which is why I enjoyed it.

Ryan: And while I’m speaking of scenes that were wisely omitted, what on Middle-earth was with that whirlwind romance between Faramir and Eowyn? They’d met, what, twice? I’ll grant that even when I originally saw RotK, the strange sexual tension between Aragorn and Eowyn, and Aragorn’s eventual rejection of her affections, left me a little sad for Eowyn and a little angry with Aragorn. I mean, is it just me, or was he totally leading her on from the moment they met? But even with that in mind, Jackson’s attempt to give Eowyn her happy ending by bringing her and Faramir together was poorly executed, and I’m glad that never made it into the theatrical cut.

Luke: Eowyn was totally playing all those dudes off of each other in an elaborate move to assert her proto-feminist agenda and take the glory by cutting down the black rider on the battlefield. And the chumps fell right into her trap. In seriousness, though, I agree the love triangles were one of the weakest elements of the series. Marks for the effort to make these elements accessible for a modern audience, but they didn’t quite sit with the way the other stuff was operating dramatically. But the arthouse spinoff feature, Eowyn and Aragon Take Broth, would make a lovely extra on the 145-disc set one day. In fact, I’ve ordered a copy for you Ryan, just in time for Christmas. Another spinoff movie that I would love to see — and Peter Jackson could go back to his Meet the Feebles sensibility to make it — would be a knockabout buddy comedy set in the ranks of the Orc army. Seriously, those guys are so pent up and angry seemingly all the time, I found myself laughing at their filthy antics and wondering if there were moments during the day where they were just hanging out, playing cards and talking about their crappy paychecks. There’d be some quality slobbering and slapstick in that movie, and I’m always in for that on film. Get Guillermo del Toro on it.

Tag Cloud

Spectrum Originals Heroines Classic Film batman crime drama Winter TV sag awards obituary versus halloween VH1 movies finale TruTV reboot Mary Poppins Returns movie comiccon TNT Mary Tyler Moore unscripted ABC HBO Max BBC America adventure cooking screenings Anna Paquin dark Warner Bros. Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Adult Swim Mudbound spinoff strong female leads Grammys Amazon Studios 45 E3 stand-up comedy Awards TV social media thriller Lifetime CW Seed news HBO Go indiana jones golden globes Disney+ Disney Plus boxoffice vampires PBS Animation Apple TV+ foreign ratings Reality Competition doctor who Trophy Talk Spring TV technology satire christmas movies YouTube Premium Star Wars Ghostbusters name the review Country Emmy Nominations adaptation festivals Election TCM stoner Horror 4/20 Lucasfilm all-time OneApp robots child's play Awards Tour TCA Winter 2020 Superheroe Rocketman comics documentaries Mindy Kaling Sundance Now Marvel Studios FX mockumentary Calendar Film PlayStation Television Critics Association Video Games Winners venice space spain Film Festival Vudu spanish language Ellie Kemper TLC 2020 Funimation HBO best TCA Awards BAFTA Amazon Prime dc hist worst Red Carpet Marvel First Look indie 2016 directors FXX CBS All Access Amazon MSNBC binge Kids & Family game show teaser Paramount Network sitcom Freeform BET Awards Year in Review Action Nat Geo green book Avengers dogs zombies DC streaming service biography harry potter Fall TV GLAAD 2018 Arrowverse Fox News IFC south america AMC Rom-Com Nominations discovery fast and furious VOD independent Family Women's History Month LGBTQ jamie lee curtis FX on Hulu Holiday 2017 Chernobyl Biopics docudrama Teen blaxploitation streaming reviews based on movie DC Universe animated Television Academy USA video on demand Crackle Set visit TV Land OWN Sneak Peek Nickelodeon television documentary ABC Family die hard CNN films Captain marvel Star Trek Syfy Pop TV Reality Epix 21st Century Fox aliens kids BET werewolf YouTube Red award winner Song of Ice and Fire cartoon medical drama Cartoon Network LGBT Western Starz cancelled Martial Arts Schedule sports GIFs PaleyFest 007 miniseries First Reviews Quiz Apple TV Plus Chilling Adventures of Sabrina football 2019 comedies Rock dceu Music Holidays science fiction historical drama political drama singing competition IFC Films BBC One hispanic Tubi TCA crossover Esquire Super Bowl Binge Guide Summer Sundance TV President period drama rotten supernatural A&E police drama Travel Channel Writers Guild of America canceled mission: impossible Sundance spider-man Drama rotten movies we love free movies A24 Paramount ESPN VICE nature Christmas cults Disney Channel CBS video The CW dramedy Character Guide disaster Comedy YA emmy awards The Walking Dead MCU RT History National Geographic Superheroes NBC Black History Month quibi Brie Larson comic joker romantic comedy Acorn TV Photos Oscars blockbuster Polls and Games Walt Disney Pictures Trivia Pet Sematary true crime Hallmark anime Cosplay NYCC cancelled television DirecTV richard e. Grant FOX revenge classics USA Network Lifetime Christmas movies Shondaland sequel cars American Society of Cinematographers Interview festival Sci-Fi Columbia Pictures nbcuniversal zero dark thirty 24 frames Bravo anthology 72 Emmy Awards RT21 franchise GoT remakes theme song scary movies Musical History Premiere Dates MTV Peacock asian-american talk show TV renewals Fantasy SXSW Spike SundanceTV Ovation nfl Valentine's Day Logo Thanksgiving 20th Century Fox Comic Book YouTube Mystery what to watch Baby Yoda parents The Purge justice league Food Network hollywood SDCC DGA Musicals Trailer Marathons canceled TV shows politics San Diego Comic-Con war facebook twilight See It Skip It ITV TIFF Netflix zombie Pirates children's TV chucky ghosts Comics on TV witnail El Rey Watching Series Best and Worst Hulu Hear Us Out New York Comic Con elevated horror serial killer BBC Stephen King Box Office Masterpiece criterion Academy Awards Extras cops Tumblr cancelled TV shows toronto concert Infographic travel worst movies mutant E! screen actors guild Shudder romance Discovery Channel cats Creative Arts Emmys Podcast series spy thriller latino DC Comics Elton John dragons universal monsters Turner Classic Movies composers Tomatazos stop motion sequels Pride Month CMT critics psychological thriller Showtime Disney streaming service scorecard Universal crime thriller cinemax Mary poppins Black Mirror Pixar slashers Britbox Comedy Central WarnerMedia Disney Plus TCA 2017 2015 Pop renewed TV shows crime casting Amazon Prime Video APB Rocky Certified Fresh Endgame Opinion Netflix Christmas movies X-Men game of thrones Apple toy story The Arrangement a nightmare on elm street breaking bad Crunchyroll transformers The Witch Countdown TBS tv talk book cancelled TV series Sony Pictures WGN Turner diversity psycho Tarantino Marvel Television Lionsgate Toys Emmys laika Cannes Disney Dark Horse Comics Hallmark Christmas movies 71st Emmy Awards superhero natural history