Watchmen First Reviews: HBO Comic Book Sequel Series Impresses

Damon Lindelof's series is a compelling take on the iconic comic book world Alan Moore and Dave Gibbons built.

by | October 15, 2019 | Comments

Damon Lindelof (The Leftovers, Lost) returns to HBO with his rendition of Watchmen, the first live-action television series adaptation of Alan Moore and Dave Gibbons’ iconic graphic novel series. The original 12-issues told explored an alternate 1985 reality where America is on the brink of nuclear war.

The story kicks off after the mysterious murder of a vigilante known as The Comedian provokes his peers — a group of heroes including the inkblot mask-wearing Rorschach, the Batman-esque Nite Owl, Silk Spectre, and otherworldly Dr. Manhattan — to come out of retirement to investigate the crime, leading them to an epic conflict with supervillain Ozymandias. All the while the Doomsday Clock continues ticking closer to midnight.

It’s 34 years later in HBO’s Watchmen and in this tale, both law enforcement and criminals hide behind masks. A white supremacist group in Tulsa, Oklahoma, has taken to using Rorschach’s iconic inkblot mask to further their own terrorist agenda and tensions are boiling over.

The series boasts a roster of heavy-hitting talent, including Leftovers alum Regina King as Detective Angela Abar, Jeremy Irons as Adrian Veidt (aka Ozymandias), Jean Smart as FBI Agent Laurie Blake (aka Silk Spectre), Don Johnson as Chief Judd Crawford, and Louis Gossett Jr. as Will Reeves.

Lindelof previously described his version of Watchmen as a remix — not a reboot — and revealed to EW that his series should be considered a sequel, acknowledging Moore and Gibbons’ comics as canon. Zack Snyder’s polarizing movie adaptation of the comics came out 10 years ago to mixed reviews — it has a 64% Tomatometer score on 306 reviews — leaving many die-hard fans disappointed. Will Lindelof’s take on the landmark tale fall into the style-over-substance trap, as well?

Here’s what critics are saying about the premiere episode of HBO’s Watchmen:

(Photo by Mark Hill/HBO)


Lindelof and his team have done the impossible – they’ve captured the superhero deconstruction elements that stood out in Moore and Gibbons’ work while also expanding on their world-building. The end result is destined to be one of the year’s most compelling shows.
– Chris Evangelista, SlashFilm

Hard to know where this will go, but the pilot is certainly dazzling and bold.
– Roger Catlin,

Ultimately, getting into the minutiae will be for uber fans. Everybody else will probably just roll with the joyfully creative explosion of weirdness that sits within Lindelof’s Watchmen.
– Tim Goodman, The Hollywood Reporter

Watchmen doesn’t overdose on nostalgia, like so many franchise extensions in our reboot-soaked decade. It’s dangerous, and invigorating.
Darren Franich, EW

Lindelof’s Watchmen is bold, creative and challenging, maintaining a faithfulness to the source material, or its spirit, at least, without being overly reverential (we’re looking at you, Zack Snyder).
– Kevin Melrose, CBR

Overall, Lindelof’s Watchmen embraces the spirit of the original comic with its stylish cynicism while attempting to erect a new organizing principle all its own, which will prove controversial to some.
– Brandon Katz, Observer


Though an ensemble piece, the story always circles back to Angela, and King plays her beautifully as a woman determined to work for justice who has to continually reevaluate what that means.
– Keith Phipps, TV Guide

The strength of Watchmen is its talented cast – which also includes Don Johnson, Hong Chau and Tim Blake Nelson. Like Lost, the best episodes are character-driven and laden with flashbacks.
– Kelly Lawler, USA Today

King is nothing short of amazing — yes, she’s got an Oscar and three Emmys, but she puts even more range on display in a turn that effortlessly pivots between invulnerable and vulnerable.
– Ben Travers, IndieWire

Irons and King crush every second (snarling or riffing quotable lines in perfect, GIF-able snippets), but they’re just part of a vast and talented ensemble that includes highlights like standoffish, totally believable child acting from Dylan Schombing and a new, delightful facet of Hong Chau.
– Jacob Oller, Paste Magazine

(Photo by Mark Hill/HBO)


Watchmen’s debut episode falls short of saying anything interesting or insightful about its subject matter, seemingly content to be a mirror of our society, albeit a seriously distorted one.
– Charles Pulliam-Moore, IO9

Watchmen holds the potential to reframe historical perspective and enduring societal truths by inviting us to a fastidiously detailed alternate America that still feels too close for comfort.
– Haleigh Foutch, Collider

That Watchmen finds within the graphic novel a story about modern race relations is both admirable and probably wrongheaded, an element that the show more successfully whispers than shouts about.
– Daniel D’Addario, Variety

Perhaps because it’s juggling so many ideas, the series feels muddled in its politics, and it’s hard not to yearn for a greater sense of urgency. Those drawbacks don’t entirely undermine Watchmen‘s pleasures, but they do blunt and distract from them.
– Brian Lowry, CNN

RELATED: Everything We Know About HBO’s Watchmen TV Series

Watchmen premieres at 9 p.m. on Sunday, October 20 on HBO.

Watchmen: Season 1 (2019)

Adjusted Score: 103.917%
Critics Consensus: Bold and bristling, Watchmen isn't always easy viewing, but by adding new layers of cultural context and a host of complex characters it expertly builds on its source material to create an impressive identity of its own.
Synopsis: Damon Lindelof (The Leftovers, Lost) creates a modern-day re-imagining of Alan Moore's groundbreaking graphic novel about masked vigilantes.... [More]

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

TLC Dark Horse Comics nature Stephen King Tomatazos YouTube Premium hispanic franchise Best and Worst science fiction quibi canceled movie cults period drama Set visit IFC Films Turner Photos NBC Nickelodeon robots ghosts Crunchyroll CMT nbcuniversal christmas movies Superheroe stop motion A&E Spring TV Rocky war Syfy Writers Guild of America Warner Bros. Musical OWN BET Schedule Universal RT21 television The Arrangement E! New York Comic Con 24 frames Family superhero crime thriller Star Trek Mary Poppins Returns cancelled TV shows Discovery Channel Crackle movies Hallmark DC Universe Pixar BAFTA Marvel Studios Paramount werewolf DC Comics SundanceTV binge dceu Spike The Witch boxoffice Freeform Comic Book Amazon Prime Tubi technology TCA Winter 2020 Ghostbusters anime OneApp singing competition universal monsters TIFF police drama animated Paramount Network Countdown disaster IFC indiana jones DC streaming service news Star Wars ratings FX Watching Series 2019 independent criterion 4/20 mockumentary tv talk Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt twilight Heroines Song of Ice and Fire supernatural TV Sundance TV Epix true crime Captain marvel zombies stand-up comedy name the review GoT cops a nightmare on elm street Chernobyl golden globes Cartoon Network Britbox WGN toy story Interview WarnerMedia TNT Pride Month romantic comedy vampires Video Games Christmas cooking breaking bad cancelled television mission: impossible Certified Fresh FX on Hulu Binge Guide 20th Century Fox finale Lifetime Christmas movies Mary poppins Premiere Dates Fall TV best Nat Geo Extras CBS All Access A24 die hard American Society of Cinematographers doctor who Classic Film Grammys hollywood Television Academy harry potter FXX Hallmark Christmas movies what to watch biography Anna Paquin medical drama stoner Sneak Peek E3 sag awards Superheroes Drama Starz sports Podcast game of thrones DirecTV MCU Vudu revenge Country emmy awards Teen joker Funimation Women's History Month The CW Walt Disney Pictures GIFs Film Festival Disney Channel BET Awards Comedy based on movie Opinion renewed TV shows Black Mirror satire Bravo Rom-Com Mystery Election hist reviews Calendar Comics on TV blaxploitation LGBTQ VH1 cars cinemax thriller 71st Emmy Awards Avengers Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Summer El Rey TruTV casting children's TV BBC One CW Seed Columbia Pictures video on demand Mudbound Masterpiece 007 halloween Peacock composers space comedies chucky spain Biopics 2016 jamie lee curtis Lionsgate asian-american Animation Acorn TV The Walking Dead See It Skip It laika cancelled slashers justice league FOX Reality Competition X-Men latino Comedy Central spider-man TBS films GLAAD Trailer PBS historical drama 2015 First Look Pop TV teaser Nominations Trivia RT History TCM unscripted Music comiccon facebook YA Super Bowl dragons free movies Sundance Now Disney streaming service versus transformers Thanksgiving social media Netflix Showtime AMC 2017 witnail History adventure spanish language crossover Toys Ellie Kemper Cosplay TCA Awards HBO Max cats LGBT Esquire series Food Network discovery Cannes Disney+ Disney Plus Marathons Spectrum Originals elevated horror Box Office Pop mutant Baby Yoda streaming VICE cartoon Disney Plus SXSW Character Guide SDCC CNN Quiz Television Critics Association miniseries Black History Month rotten Marvel Television documentary YouTube Red documentaries Turner Classic Movies Tarantino Infographic Amazon Studios MTV Horror zombie Disney Valentine's Day indie Year in Review all-time green book fast and furious aliens The Purge CBS First Reviews Hulu classics Fox News screenings dogs Academy Awards ESPN obituary Brie Larson Holiday foreign Kids & Family BBC political drama screen actors guild psychological thriller Western zero dark thirty ABC Family Arrowverse PaleyFest Sci-Fi Tumblr Martial Arts batman crime video Musicals sequels Reality TV renewals Netflix Christmas movies USA Network sitcom Film serial killer concert dark ABC festivals comic Mary Tyler Moore sequel Emmy Nominations reboot Lucasfilm crime drama Sundance President TV Land TCA romance TCA 2017 game show kids Red Carpet canceled TV shows scary movies south america Hear Us Out strong female leads San Diego Comic-Con MSNBC psycho Travel Channel Rocketman richard e. Grant Polls and Games YouTube BBC America Apple HBO Go Pet Sematary Action award winner dramedy Awards Tour travel USA Winter TV natural history dc Logo adaptation parents child's play book Marvel Rock Amazon Emmys comics 21st Century Fox 72 Emmy Awards worst cancelled TV series 2020 NYCC Creative Arts Emmys theme song DGA Shudder Awards Holidays PlayStation spinoff anthology Trophy Talk rotten movies we love docudrama National Geographic spy thriller HBO Endgame APB Adult Swim Pirates Sony Pictures VOD Elton John talk show blockbuster ITV 45 diversity Apple TV Plus Oscars Winners politics Amazon Prime Video critics Ovation 2018 Apple TV+ directors Fantasy Lifetime Mindy Kaling Shondaland