Showdowns

Wes Craven Vs. John Carpenter: Who Is the Ultimate Master of Horror?

Who has the Fresher movies, bigger box office, and more terrifying moments? It's our bloodiest battle yet.

by | October 14, 2020 | Comments

One gave us Michael Myers and the Thing, the other Freddy Krueger and Ghostface – and both gave us many, many sleepless nights. But who is the king of making us quake? In our latest episode of Vs., we’re slicing and dicing the numbers to find out who is the true master of horror: John Carpenter or Wes Craven. Will it be the famed director – and killer composer – who essentially defined the slasher genre with Halloween? Or will it be Craven, who let us know that danger lurked under the stairs, in the last house on the left, and in our dreams? Our favorite Final Boy and Rotten Tomatoes contributing editor Mark Ellis is examining Tomatometer and Audience Score data, box office performance, iconic moments and characters from their films, to make a call. And if you don’t agree, have at him: He’s just putting on some Jiffy Pop right now and his phone number is… we mean, let us know in the comments!


On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.


Thumbnail image: © New Line, © First Run Features

Tag Cloud

Comics on TV Ovation 2021 Winter TV Extras franchise 2019 PBS TLC Comedy romance 2017 Ellie Kemper Captain marvel Action Masterpiece spider-man crossover indie action-comedy Pop 2016 crime drama Binge Guide remakes Endgame TruTV jamie lee curtis Paramount Plus reviews 21st Century Fox king kong Marathons video Pride Month strong female leads nfl VOD PaleyFest GIFs The Walt Disney Company toy story 4/20 E! Hulu Elton John international IFC Films Set visit Song of Ice and Fire Heroines adventure Creative Arts Emmys werewolf Musicals PlayStation A24 psycho Tomatazos Chernobyl all-time cancelled hispanic heritage month critics TCA Winter 2020 marvel comics foreign Reality Red Carpet Mary poppins CNN ESPN Classic Film Shudder TV movies Pet Sematary Tarantino worst movies comics FX Infographic medical drama Fall TV comic books casting Crunchyroll spanish screen actors guild transformers renewed TV shows children's TV BAFTA mockumentary zombie TNT HBO Go 45 science fiction Baby Yoda twilight Mary Tyler Moore directors technology Fox News talk show Food Network mission: impossible wonder woman YA crime thriller Cosplay Arrowverse TCM Quiz Sci-Fi adaptation true crime San Diego Comic-Con football live action ViacomCBS Fantasy Brie Larson Comedy Central Instagram Live boxing independent A&E 2020 Film Festival Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt natural history Video Games golden globe awards Western cops Sony Pictures news criterion Holiday films FX on Hulu supernatural australia Calendar Tubi Television Academy psychological thriller aliens documentary Character Guide robots Photos vampires revenge suspense VH1 E3 emmy awards RT History live event 72 Emmy Awards kids series GLAAD parents YouTube Premium book adaptation Sneak Peek Britbox sequel Syfy rt archives NBC police drama anthology Pixar The CW 73rd Emmy Awards President blockbuster festival theme song Winners Disney Channel cinemax blaxploitation Premiere Dates SundanceTV DC Universe TV Land 2015 National Geographic vs. MCU ratings Cannes jurassic park cooking finale kong book boxoffice indiana jones Podcast Starz japan AMC Plus satire DC streaming service DC Comics Family high school posters Freeform debate comiccon Image Comics OWN batman Dark Horse Comics royal family SXSW adenture canceled dramedy HBO Max war Acorn TV Nickelodeon Black History Month hist Turner critic resources Hallmark king arthur Universal FOX Sundance TV reboot Comic-Con@Home 2021 Awards Apple Country justice league versus Marvel Television First Look rotten movies we love joker stop motion slasher romantic comedy hidden camera venice Lifetime Christmas movies sopranos VICE Broadway Music TIFF thriller LGBT Opinion rotten pirates of the caribbean Spectrum Originals 90s Horror gangster Polls and Games BET Awards sitcom Valentine's Day Neflix black deadpool Rocky RT21 saw target television Nat Geo Showtime streaming comic book movies what to watch The Purge james bond superman christmas movies harry potter FXX canceled TV shows doctor who women dceu biopic comedies spy thriller WGN documentaries Emmy Nominations 99% Hear Us Out TBS The Arrangement social media Alien Interview green book Toys TV hollywood Mystery SDCC space dogs First Reviews latino USA Network animated CMT heist movie Rocketman Tumblr Disney spain godzilla spider-verse asian-american Mudbound miniseries festivals french Grammys scary mob Esquire MSNBC TCA Star Trek free movies concert Box Office diversity new star wars movies universal monsters Biopics Trophy Talk Trailer dreamworks Travel Channel mcc rom-coms Spring TV Mindy Kaling Emmys feel good japanese mutant slashers Watching Series ABC Family BET obituary binge Paramount Netflix Christmas movies Apple TV Plus composers Shondaland Martial Arts young adult Peacock cancelled TV series HBO archives worst YouTube Red Walt Disney Pictures New York Comic Con Stephen King classics politics game of thrones dexter Holidays fresh Countdown popular MTV olympics Musical hispanic ITV TV One NBA WarnerMedia 1990s Pacific Islander El Rey Bravo Marvel Studios richard e. Grant fast and furious Women's History Month Reality Competition scene in color Netflix Adult Swim Paramount Network Amazon Prime dc CBS All Access game show Schedule marvel cinematic universe Vudu 20th Century Fox monster movies video on demand Anna Paquin trailers zero dark thirty spanish language Lifetime blockbusters Best and Worst Writers Guild of America period drama spinoff BBC One Star Wars 2018 BBC America sequels BBC Awards Tour Amazon basketball Nominations Warner Bros. Turner Classic Movies Legendary cancelled television DirecTV Kids & Family Lucasfilm cancelled TV shows art house See It Skip It die hard Animation cartoon The Walking Dead genre Fox Searchlight AMC GoT award winner Disney+ Disney Plus ABC halloween tv Year in Review zombies Marvel scorecard American Society of Cinematographers Comic Book Hallmark Christmas movies superhero Academy Awards Pirates sports based on movie IFC a nightmare on elm street anime ABC Signature CW Seed Universal Pictures USA YouTube The Academy new york stoner Superheroe halloween lord of the rings Rom-Com toronto Oscars Ghostbusters Spike The Witch NYCC dark Summer Avengers telelvision X-Men APB stand-up comedy teaser political drama Mary Poppins Returns Christmas laika 71st Emmy Awards DGA unscripted crime historical drama rt labs critics edition Discovery Channel streaming movies aapi TCA Awards black comedy Election Sundance Now facebook Columbia Pictures Epix TV renewals dragons Cartoon Network 007 ID cats Certified Fresh docuseries movie Wes Anderson Exclusive Video comic elevated horror sag awards chucky Sundance serial killer golden globes docudrama Tokyo Olympics razzies legend Disney Plus Film scary movies cars 93rd Oscars Amazon Studios OneApp witnail screenings comic book movie child's play Rock History cults TCA 2017 Apple TV+ Black Mirror south america name the review nature tv talk Amazon Prime Video Funimation Television Critics Association LGBTQ disaster know your critic biography Trivia breaking bad Disney streaming service nbcuniversal 24 frames Superheroes Teen kaiju singing competition Pop TV CBS best Super Bowl italian IMDb TV Drama movies ghosts Lionsgate 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards prank travel Logo quibi Chilling Adventures of Sabrina rt labs discovery new zealand Crackle Thanksgiving