What We Do in the Shadows First Reviews: Hilarious Series Lives Up to Film

The upcoming series based on the 2015 film has a different cast and is set in Staten Island instead of New Zealand — how does it hold up?

by and | March 11, 2019 | Comments

What We Do in the Shadows, the hilarious 2015 mockumentary film about vampire roommates that was co-written by, co-directed by, and co-starred Jemaine Clement and Taika Waititi, charmed critics (if not giant theater-going audiences) and is Certified Fresh with 96% on 192 reviews. Now that the film is available for streaming and has secured its cult status, Clement and Waititi have applied its special sauce to a new FX series, starring new actors and set on New York’s Staten Island.

The series premiered at the SXSW film festival in Austin on Friday, which saw the release of giddy reviews praising the show, which stars Kayvan Novak (Four Lions), Natasia Demetriou (Stath Lets Flats), Matt Berry (Toast of London), and Mark Proksch (Better Call Saul) as vampires Nandor, Nadja, Laszlo, and Colin Robinson, respectively, and Harvey Guillén (The Magicians) as their human servant Guillermo.

What are the critics saying? Here’s are the first impressions of FX show What We Do in the Shadows:

How does it compare to the film?

FX’s new take on What We Do In The Shadows transplants the same approach, expressionism, and aesthetic of Waititi and Clement’s effortlessly entertaining “vampire world-shattering documentary” from New Zealand to Staten Island.
Matt Donato, Slashfilm

It’s, well, more of the same, but just as deliciously delightful, absurd and wry in is amusing observations of banal vampire co-habitation, rituals and customs… it reveals the basic concept as a rich vein that could be sucked on for years.
Rodrigo Perez, The Playlist

Functionally, the show and the film are different beasts, and you feel it in both the storytelling and the comedy.
Haleigh Foutch, Collider

WHAT WE DO IN THE SHADOWS season 1 keyart (FX)

(Photo by FX)

Does the adaptation to TV work?

The adaptation is just the right amount of weird paired with just the right amount of sweet paired with just the right amount of dark.
Merrill Barr, Forbes

What We Do in the Shadows should have always been a series. Simply put, there’s just so much you can do with this premise, and the first four episodes alone proves as much… Absolutely nothing has been lost in translation.
Michael Roffman, Consequence of Sound

Sometimes it feels like certain details are rushed in favor of a silly joke, but a) the silly jokes are so good, and b) the intricate craftsmanship evident in the costumes, sets, and over mise en scéne, not to mention the rich world-building and endearing characters, more than make up for a few early bumps.
Ben Travers, IndieWire

Does the humor hold up?

It’s this grandly goofy collision of the supernatural and the mundane that makes Shadows such a giddy joy to watch — and maybe the funniest new show of the year so far.
Dave Nemetz, TV Line

This show’s laughs are closer to chuckles than guffaws.
– Daniel D’Addario, Variety

What We Do in the Shadows mines plenty of effective humor from the vampires’ discomfort with the human world, but much like the movie, the series really shines in the banter between the cast, and the surreal nature of their various supernatural abilities.
– Laura Prudom, IGN Movies

Will we miss Clement and Waititi on screen?

Waititi and Clement stay off camera this time around, but still divide directorial and executive producing duties on the FX series, with Clement also writing a number of episodes alongside executive producer Paul Simms.
Laura Prudom, IGN Movies

One of the more troubling notions going into this series was whether or not the cast would be able to match the chemistry of the 2014 film… Rest assured, it’s one that paid off as this ensemble is, dare we say, even stronger?
– Michael Roffman, Consequence of Sound

How’s the acting?

The cast is bursting with gems, too. I must confess I’ve never seen Novak, Guillén, or Demetriou in anything before, but they’re all superb, nailing the show’s bone-dry comedic tone right away.
– Dave Nemetz, TV Line

Kayvan Novak, Natasia Demetrious, and Matt Berry are witty, engaging company as three eternal beings whose vanities run up against the banal reality of trying to find fresh blood.
– Daniel D’Addario, Variety

Waititi’s direction on the pilot, paired with Clement’s well-paced script, certainly plays to the actors’ strengths.
– Laura Prudom, IGN Movies

All of these cast members effectively sell these bizarre characters, but they also gel together as a group, which is a pretty crucial aspect of this series.
Daniel Kurland, Bloody Disgusting

Where does it fall in the TV mockumentary canon?

The show’s mockumentary format feels, for the first time in a while, like something new.
Daniel D’Addario, Variety

While not every joke lands, What We Do in the Shadows is a confident, charming, and creative twist on a well-worn genre.
– Laura Prudom, IGN Movies

Despite the played-out documentary film angle, it all manages to work and What We Do in the Shadows becomes addictively, ridiculously funny — part droll look at everyday vamp-ness and part inspired family sitcom.
– Tim Goodman, The Hollywood Reporter

It’s easy to say that this feels like a supernatural take on The Office, but it’s a lot more akin to a horror-fueled version of The Real World due to how these different vampires are all housed up together.
– Daniel Kurland, Bloody Disgusting

What We Do in the Shadows has all the right pieces to become another mockumentary great.
– Haleigh Foutch, Collider

Are there literal references to The Office?

Preying on co-workers in temp offices by day, Colin (Mark Proksch) is a humorous riff on cubical culture and that annoying, chatty guy at your day job who just won’t shut up about the most boring shit on earth.
– Rodrigo Perez, The Playlist

Even when they tackle more obvious tropes — such as the fluorescent purgatory of the standard American office space, which has been beaten to death by now — Waititi and Clement are able to find new life.
– Michael Roffman, Consequence of Sound

The understated Mark Proksch represents the day walking energy vampire as Colin Robinson. At one point in the series he comes across his ultimate nemesis, an emotional vampire sucking the happiness and life out of his co-workers and leaving the office as dry as the cubicles for psionic sustenance.
– Tony Sokol, Den of Geek

Final verdict?

Great movie, even better show, if only for the time you invested in that world and with those characters and with their stakes.
– Michael Roffman, Consequence of Sound

This series won’t be for everybody, but there’s nothing else quite like it, adding a freshness to the comedy selection on TV… FX has seemingly unearthed another gem.
Tim Goodman, The Hollywood Reporter

There’s a lot to admire in the opening episodes, and the potential within each only drives more excitement for the next.
Ben Travers, IndieWire

Vampires never get old and What We Do in the Shadows never gets tired of plumbing the mythology for quirky twists on old tropes.
Tony Sokol, Den of Geek

What We Do in the Shadows premieres Wednesday, March 27 on FX.

Adjusted Score: 99.378%
Critics Consensus: Delightfully absurd and ridiculously fun, What We Do in the Shadows expands on the film's vampiric lore and finds fresh perspective in its charming, off-kilter cast to create a mockumentary series worth sinking your teeth into.
Synopsis: Set in New York City, What We Do in the Shadows follows three vampires who have been roommates for hundreds... [More]

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

Superheroe cults Star Trek ESPN mockumentary Television Academy psychological thriller dark comiccon toy story remakes Film ABC Family Red Carpet Broadway video on demand revenge screenings slashers 2015 FXX Emmy Nominations toronto CBS All Access A&E Comic Book Martial Arts talk show WarnerMedia green book discovery Disney justice league History anime Lionsgate twilight Ovation singing competition Super Bowl Mystery mission: impossible mutant El Rey cats Western halloween Black History Month stoner australia DC Comics popular The Witch Apple Rom-Com Toys adventure BAFTA emmy awards classics TCA Winter 2020 superhero 2020 LGBT kong unscripted Sneak Peek sequel Nat Geo Classic Film Spike serial killer The Academy Turner Classic Movies dc stop motion indiana jones children's TV archives Comedy Central Polls and Games Sci-Fi dramedy TruTV USA Podcast kids zombie dogs CMT Hallmark Christmas movies comedies Mary Tyler Moore MTV richard e. Grant Superheroes The CW Best and Worst canceled TV shows hidden camera Awards Tour worst godzilla Trivia free movies Dark Horse Comics HBO monster movies E! directors venice canceled Epix Animation films OWN NBC TV 21st Century Fox Spring TV Song of Ice and Fire worst movies medical drama sag awards cancelled television ratings cops deadpool comics Paramount Plus supernatural war thriller movies PlayStation Sundance Schedule Trophy Talk Black Mirror Bravo aliens Britbox Certified Fresh Mary Poppins Returns Star Wars Photos Disney streaming service elevated horror hollywood facebook 2017 nature Writers Guild of America Marathons Trailer 2018 rom-coms lord of the rings ABC Signature video Television Critics Association docudrama APB Amazon Studios Fall TV new star wars movies razzies nbcuniversal trailers Comedy Watching Series Countdown First Look Lifetime Christmas movies Hulu See It Skip It Valentine's Day Musicals boxoffice football satire MSNBC Apple TV Plus Comics on TV Showtime PaleyFest Tarantino political drama latino new york New York Comic Con travel HBO Go blaxploitation DC Universe ABC blockbuster zero dark thirty casting 007 foreign Creative Arts Emmys Spectrum Originals Warner Bros. Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Binge Guide Year in Review The Walking Dead First Reviews Horror criterion south america Freeform Action Country Mudbound X-Men police drama documentaries what to watch FX on Hulu Musical parents strong female leads CBS harry potter animated natural history joker TCA 2017 spider-man movie politics italian 2021 Election sitcom werewolf award winner Discovery Channel Ellie Kemper Mindy Kaling Holidays Logo Nickelodeon reboot TV movies Disney Channel christmas movies OneApp SDCC 2016 Music FX cancelled TV series vampires romance spanish language Quiz cooking king kong critics boxing Amazon Shondaland Heroines transformers nfl rt archives streaming Ghostbusters VOD Character Guide women Columbia Pictures teaser RT History Food Network cancelled Tubi ITV docuseries Adult Swim robots book Exclusive Video Fantasy news BBC Rock TV Land 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards The Arrangement rotten PBS Acorn TV TLC Netflix Christmas movies RT21 die hard BBC One VH1 a nightmare on elm street period drama witnail Universal game show TCM name the review Baby Yoda theme song finale Oscars Grammys Calendar Esquire child's play Disney+ Disney Plus superman asian-american scorecard Marvel composers Box Office Elton John Video Games universal monsters series fresh 4/20 renewed TV shows sports Funimation Mary poppins diversity new zealand Stephen King Pet Sematary hispanic adaptation Brie Larson Summer Hallmark festival Walt Disney Pictures Reality Fox News international SXSW Crackle Apple TV+ IFC high school Family pirates of the caribbean technology tv talk Rocky hist live action television 71st Emmy Awards AMC based on movie all-time aapi 20th Century Fox golden globe awards Legendary batman Endgame Christmas MCU GIFs anthology TBS versus target prank Shudder space NYCC TCA Extras CW Seed Disney Plus Sundance TV crime IFC Films Reality Competition miniseries DC streaming service scene in color festivals Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Turner Lifetime Premiere Dates Cannes cinemax WGN game of thrones Tumblr screen actors guild japanese SundanceTV true crime Rocketman fast and furious 2019 Marvel Television National Geographic 45 Syfy 72 Emmy Awards crossover Winners james bond Travel Channel DirecTV saw Anna Paquin 93rd Oscars black Emmys Pop Vudu halloween tv HBO Max Thanksgiving Chernobyl spy thriller BET Awards Starz TIFF Image Comics Holiday YouTube Red USA Network kaiju indie crime thriller telelvision TCA Awards Awards Netflix Pride Month Lucasfilm Crunchyroll scary movies Arrowverse stand-up comedy french CNN GLAAD spanish psycho Alien YouTube President Cosplay Infographic FOX Women's History Month Teen TV renewals YA Biopics dceu book adaptation Film Festival The Walt Disney Company quibi jamie lee curtis Hear Us Out dragons historical drama crime drama comic Captain marvel BET concert know your critic chucky Pop TV Pirates disaster 99% Peacock blockbusters franchise TNT YouTube Premium Pixar marvel cinematic universe American Society of Cinematographers spinoff Amazon Prime Video Winter TV Tomatazos spain Opinion GoT Drama cartoon ID romantic comedy Masterpiece ghosts 24 frames Marvel Studios A24 biography LGBTQ science fiction jurassic park Set visit reviews Fox Searchlight Amazon Prime binge laika cancelled TV shows Sundance Now breaking bad Paramount Network E3 The Purge Pacific Islander rotten movies we love streaming movies Paramount ViacomCBS independent DGA zombies documentary Academy Awards Cartoon Network golden globes cars social media Avengers obituary Nominations Sony Pictures Interview BBC America comic books best Kids & Family doctor who VICE San Diego Comic-Con heist movie TV One sequels