What We Do in the Shadows First Reviews: Hilarious Series Lives Up to Film

The upcoming series based on the 2015 film has a different cast and is set in Staten Island instead of New Zealand — how does it hold up?

by and | March 11, 2019 | Comments

What We Do in the Shadows, the hilarious 2015 mockumentary film about vampire roommates that was co-written by, co-directed by, and co-starred Jemaine Clement and Taika Waititi, charmed critics (if not giant theater-going audiences) and is Certified Fresh with 96% on 192 reviews. Now that the film is available for streaming and has secured its cult status, Clement and Waititi have applied its special sauce to a new FX series, starring new actors and set on New York’s Staten Island.

The series premiered at the SXSW film festival in Austin on Friday, which saw the release of giddy reviews praising the show, which stars Kayvan Novak (Four Lions), Natasia Demetriou (Stath Lets Flats), Matt Berry (Toast of London), and Mark Proksch (Better Call Saul) as vampires Nandor, Nadja, Laszlo, and Colin Robinson, respectively, and Harvey Guillén (The Magicians) as their human servant Guillermo.

What are the critics saying? Here’s are the first impressions of FX show What We Do in the Shadows:

How does it compare to the film?

FX’s new take on What We Do In The Shadows transplants the same approach, expressionism, and aesthetic of Waititi and Clement’s effortlessly entertaining “vampire world-shattering documentary” from New Zealand to Staten Island.
Matt Donato, Slashfilm

It’s, well, more of the same, but just as deliciously delightful, absurd and wry in is amusing observations of banal vampire co-habitation, rituals and customs… it reveals the basic concept as a rich vein that could be sucked on for years.
Rodrigo Perez, The Playlist

Functionally, the show and the film are different beasts, and you feel it in both the storytelling and the comedy.
Haleigh Foutch, Collider

WHAT WE DO IN THE SHADOWS season 1 keyart (FX)
(Photo by FX)

Does the adaptation to TV work?

The adaptation is just the right amount of weird paired with just the right amount of sweet paired with just the right amount of dark.
Merrill Barr, Forbes

What We Do in the Shadows should have always been a series. Simply put, there’s just so much you can do with this premise, and the first four episodes alone proves as much… Absolutely nothing has been lost in translation.
Michael Roffman, Consequence of Sound

Sometimes it feels like certain details are rushed in favor of a silly joke, but a) the silly jokes are so good, and b) the intricate craftsmanship evident in the costumes, sets, and over mise en scéne, not to mention the rich world-building and endearing characters, more than make up for a few early bumps.
Ben Travers, IndieWire

Does the humor hold up?

It’s this grandly goofy collision of the supernatural and the mundane that makes Shadows such a giddy joy to watch — and maybe the funniest new show of the year so far.
Dave Nemetz, TV Line

This show’s laughs are closer to chuckles than guffaws.
– Daniel D’Addario, Variety

What We Do in the Shadows mines plenty of effective humor from the vampires’ discomfort with the human world, but much like the movie, the series really shines in the banter between the cast, and the surreal nature of their various supernatural abilities.
– Laura Prudom, IGN Movies

Will we miss Clement and Waititi on screen?

Waititi and Clement stay off camera this time around, but still divide directorial and executive producing duties on the FX series, with Clement also writing a number of episodes alongside executive producer Paul Simms.
Laura Prudom, IGN Movies

One of the more troubling notions going into this series was whether or not the cast would be able to match the chemistry of the 2014 film… Rest assured, it’s one that paid off as this ensemble is, dare we say, even stronger?
– Michael Roffman, Consequence of Sound

How’s the acting?

The cast is bursting with gems, too. I must confess I’ve never seen Novak, Guillén, or Demetriou in anything before, but they’re all superb, nailing the show’s bone-dry comedic tone right away.
– Dave Nemetz, TV Line

Kayvan Novak, Natasia Demetrious, and Matt Berry are witty, engaging company as three eternal beings whose vanities run up against the banal reality of trying to find fresh blood.
– Daniel D’Addario, Variety

Waititi’s direction on the pilot, paired with Clement’s well-paced script, certainly plays to the actors’ strengths.
– Laura Prudom, IGN Movies

All of these cast members effectively sell these bizarre characters, but they also gel together as a group, which is a pretty crucial aspect of this series.
Daniel Kurland, Bloody Disgusting

Where does it fall in the TV mockumentary canon?

The show’s mockumentary format feels, for the first time in a while, like something new.
Daniel D’Addario, Variety

While not every joke lands, What We Do in the Shadows is a confident, charming, and creative twist on a well-worn genre.
– Laura Prudom, IGN Movies

Despite the played-out documentary film angle, it all manages to work and What We Do in the Shadows becomes addictively, ridiculously funny — part droll look at everyday vamp-ness and part inspired family sitcom.
– Tim Goodman, The Hollywood Reporter

It’s easy to say that this feels like a supernatural take on The Office, but it’s a lot more akin to a horror-fueled version of The Real World due to how these different vampires are all housed up together.
– Daniel Kurland, Bloody Disgusting

What We Do in the Shadows has all the right pieces to become another mockumentary great.
– Haleigh Foutch, Collider

Are there literal references to The Office?

Preying on co-workers in temp offices by day, Colin (Mark Proksch) is a humorous riff on cubical culture and that annoying, chatty guy at your day job who just won’t shut up about the most boring shit on earth.
– Rodrigo Perez, The Playlist

Even when they tackle more obvious tropes — such as the fluorescent purgatory of the standard American office space, which has been beaten to death by now — Waititi and Clement are able to find new life.
– Michael Roffman, Consequence of Sound

The understated Mark Proksch represents the day walking energy vampire as Colin Robinson. At one point in the series he comes across his ultimate nemesis, an emotional vampire sucking the happiness and life out of his co-workers and leaving the office as dry as the cubicles for psionic sustenance.
– Tony Sokol, Den of Geek

Final verdict?

Great movie, even better show, if only for the time you invested in that world and with those characters and with their stakes.
– Michael Roffman, Consequence of Sound

This series won’t be for everybody, but there’s nothing else quite like it, adding a freshness to the comedy selection on TV… FX has seemingly unearthed another gem.
Tim Goodman, The Hollywood Reporter

There’s a lot to admire in the opening episodes, and the potential within each only drives more excitement for the next.
Ben Travers, IndieWire

Vampires never get old and What We Do in the Shadows never gets tired of plumbing the mythology for quirky twists on old tropes.
Tony Sokol, Den of Geek

What We Do in the Shadows premieres Wednesday, March 27 on FX.

Adjusted Score: 99.126%
Critics Consensus: Delightfully absurd and ridiculously fun, What We Do in the Shadows expands on the film's vampiric lore and finds fresh perspective in its charming, off-kilter cast to create a mockumentary series worth sinking your teeth into.
Synopsis: Set in New York City, What We Do in the Shadows follows three vampires who have been roommates for hundreds... [More]

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

harry potter Hallmark supernatural See It Skip It indie thriller Nickelodeon sequels critics MSNBC A24 PaleyFest spain dark Reality Competition Spectrum Originals films twilight vampires 2017 TNT breaking bad worst TCA 2017 what to watch Year in Review versus Interview football natural history parents Best and Worst adaptation Endgame TCA Awards Universal Summer Drama 2020 Thanksgiving comedies remakes TLC Epix children's TV Tomatazos NBC sports movie DC streaming service First Reviews Country The Walking Dead PBS transformers rotten universal monsters Women's History Month HBO Max child's play award winner GIFs Holidays Quiz Spring TV YA FX on Hulu kids Western quibi science fiction 2016 Creative Arts Emmys video Winners canceled TV shows cooking Netflix Horror Sundance Now nfl Music rotten movies we love Chilling Adventures of Sabrina french sag awards 2019 Sci-Fi San Diego Comic-Con Shudder free movies foreign SXSW Tarantino Turner screenings werewolf classics Certified Fresh Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Schedule Funimation CBS All Access dragons true crime Television Academy nbcuniversal doctor who Television Critics Association social media teaser discovery Ghostbusters BBC One Showtime a nightmare on elm street justice league Lucasfilm spy thriller OWN Turner Classic Movies Trivia superhero Christmas TBS Ellie Kemper Disney Columbia Pictures Britbox zombies Kids & Family romantic comedy diversity National Geographic period drama Rom-Com independent Amazon Rock satire Sundance TV Bravo game show LGBTQ chucky DGA Star Wars Stephen King Mystery History reboot dc Elton John Sneak Peek 24 frames LGBT dceu zombie Opinion Tubi Calendar cancelled TV series El Rey Pirates Anna Paquin ratings Pop TV Song of Ice and Fire cartoon medical drama Academy Awards Lifetime Christmas movies DC Universe Countdown RT21 anthology psycho Extras 4/20 Disney Plus Character Guide hispanic Fantasy Red Carpet police drama Black Mirror Emmy Nominations Amazon Prime E3 Mudbound concert theme song sequel Awards Tour ABC news festival PlayStation witnail screen actors guild nature finale Paramount Network golden globes documentary game of thrones YouTube Premium Black History Month cinemax romance Avengers Amazon Prime Video Dark Horse Comics comic 007 Ovation GoT 72 Emmy Awards Esquire WarnerMedia BET Awards Freeform Grammys IFC Films WGN Brie Larson VH1 mockumentary technology book Starz animated mission: impossible scorecard Crunchyroll The Arrangement best mutant The Purge AMC toy story ESPN hist TV Land SundanceTV strong female leads space 21st Century Fox jamie lee curtis green book FXX Arrowverse 71st Emmy Awards SDCC documentaries Film Festival MTV Emmys Toys TV dramedy talk show TCA Winter 2020 Masterpiece Discovery Channel Acorn TV Superheroes Spike crime thriller Peacock Hallmark Christmas movies Food Network X-Men zero dark thirty cats christmas movies Lionsgate BET ghosts robots TIFF sitcom spanish language Photos OneApp joker unscripted E! franchise spider-man asian-american Teen Set visit serial killer politics A&E directors based on movie Apple TV+ Comic Book Trailer Warner Bros. movies ABC Family slashers anime cults Comedy Central fast and furious Fall TV scary movies crime drama Mary Tyler Moore Vudu Video Games canceled Writers Guild of America Crackle psychological thriller Reality Pixar batman reviews ITV Awards tv talk APB latino Mindy Kaling TruTV Chernobyl GLAAD Shondaland festivals revenge Tumblr IFC Fox News Marvel Studios Walt Disney Pictures Amazon Studios die hard TV renewals Superheroe FX indiana jones DC Comics south america Pet Sematary all-time Classic Film halloween Family CMT aliens laika cars Valentine's Day cancelled television Fox Searchlight Election disaster DirecTV Star Trek Animation BAFTA blaxploitation The CW stand-up comedy New York Comic Con spanish TCM video on demand halloween tv binge Rocketman archives miniseries Comics on TV criterion FOX RT History First Look Binge Guide toronto singing competition Cartoon Network hollywood 2015 45 20th Century Fox Cannes blockbuster Baby Yoda Premiere Dates Rocky Adult Swim historical drama cancelled Watching Series worst movies Heroines VOD Musicals Comedy Apple Apple TV Plus elevated horror Nat Geo comics Nominations spinoff stop motion television BBC America docudrama CBS Marvel Box Office The Witch NYCC Hear Us Out italian YouTube Red Winter TV HBO Musical streaming Disney Channel Cosplay Infographic biography comiccon Pride Month facebook name the review dogs stoner Disney streaming service Mary poppins Captain marvel Hulu CNN BBC Paramount Action Pop Travel Channel series The Academy travel MCU Oscars Podcast USA Network Lifetime Sony Pictures VICE Disney+ Disney Plus venice Film CW Seed cancelled TV shows Super Bowl American Society of Cinematographers YouTube crime Martial Arts richard e. Grant casting Polls and Games Biopics USA 2018 TCA Mary Poppins Returns Logo HBO Go political drama adventure composers war President Trophy Talk obituary emmy awards crossover Holiday Marvel Television cops Syfy renewed TV shows Netflix Christmas movies Marathons Sundance boxoffice